Bhuvi's got this IMO.
So I was right, you were confusing it with IPLOkay, I've just had a check. I reckon in the last World T20, South Africa played two games that you would class as important matches. In those two he had a decent but not spectacular innings against Pakistan, and a pretty crap one against Australia. In the one knockout game of the last 50 over World Cup he was run out. In the 2010 World T20 he was the only one to stand up in the Pakistan game, which ultimately saw South Africa knockout.
You think all that is enough to make his overrated, despite the fact that he's been an absolute monster in one day cricket in the last few years and throughout his career?