Clarke claimed the system was better not used rather than used without Hotspot as the umpires could be deaf and dumb after agreeing to use it without Hotspot in the first place.
This.
No UDRS != Accept incompetent umpires. With umpires who make six mistakes a game even UDRS might not be enough to save him.
That's an alarming attitude to have. Looking forward to a spray from Dhoni against sn umpire when they make dodgy calls in his team's favour. We won't see that though, will we?
If the evidence is inconclusive, how is the decision "wrong"?This.
The 2 reviews may be exhausted because of taking reviews which can't be overturned due to inconclusive evidence but sometimes you have to take. Then what happens?
Or the review may be inconclusive in the first place as with Raina and Bravo this match.
Or the third umpire and the umpire may not do the review properly like Harper in South Africa or Ian Bell in WC . Or the broadcaster may show the wrong video
No, it was just more typical WAH WAH STUART BROAD HAS EVERYTHING HIS OWN WAY bollocksSo i take it yourwhen i criticised Chris Broad was actually a agreement?
No. They complained because the decisions went against them. What a ****ing joke, to have an umpire step down because one team has the ****s.
Was more referring to Chris rather than Stuart in that post tbh.
Exactly. Considering he did not step down after the England South Africa Fracas and many players including Nasser Hussain openly demanding his removal too.
Obviously only the aggrieved team is going to complain. He stepped down though on his own accord one test before his last one. He has been criticized similarly earlier and I don't get why he suddenly couldn't take it any more.
I might have mixed up your Chris Broad comment with someone else who mentioned him and how Stuart gets everything he wants. In which case, I take it back.Was more referring to Chris rather than Stuart in that post tbh.
And won't even bother to respond to your other post. Do you seriously have to resort at abuse and stereotyping at every oppurtunity?
And who said anything about Racism or even accused anyone or any decision directly here?
Did not know one can draw so many presumptions from a meek honest response to a question by Dhoni. * Sigh *
What the **** does Nasser Hussain have to do with any of this? He retired in 2004.Exactly. Considering he did not step down after the England South Africa Fracas and many players including Nasser Hussain openly demanding his removal too.
And ECB chairman Giles Clarke implying him to be Deaf and Dumb openly.
Also he was the one who gave Tendulkar out ducking IIRC and was criticised. And after all that he is quitting because of this comment
He though was a likeable character ,was never shy of publicity and being centre of attention.
Would not surprise me if knowing he had one match left in any case ,he was stepping down for one final moment in the limelight and for something which he can put in his book in the future to make it sell more.
I meant in terms of the Criticism and pressure he got on himself from the outside and people involved inside the game at that time was way more than one comment from Dhoni.
as you did not understand the context.
Right.
Of course there were, and half were from me. Not nearly as many, and not nearly as full of vitriol tho. And that's fine, I'm sure plenty of people did hate India from whenever they wanted for whatever reason they wanted - good luck to them. The critical mass was reached only recently though, which is what's so delicious.
