what does 'us' mean? i guess everyone is a member here irrespective of whether you are here for x yrs or y months or z days and can give his/her opinion .... does being here for x years give a Ist class upgrade in an airline or something like that?ret, there is no domestic cricket sub-forum.
As for discussing this topic, you've been here what, a month, and you're telling us what we should and shouldn't discuss? This is a very high calibre cricket forum, perhaps the highest there is and in-depth analysis into a countries cricket talent will take place. If you don't like it or are not interested, don't visit the thread. Just because you have little idea about the players being talked about, doesn't mean others also don't and don't wish to discuss these things.
it's a high calibre naughtyMost out-of-place naughty ever, even by Volty's/Cameron's standards?
Meh, the word high-calibre will take on a new meaning when I roll out my Bangladeshi 5th XI.it's a high calibre naughty
TBH, ret has had a few, but Sameer and andruid have also had more than 1 strange one, and as for Raghav...Most out-of-place naughty ever, even by Volty's/Cameron's standards?
If you feel a topic has little merit, stay out of the thread, simple as.what does 'us' mean? i guess everyone is a member here irrespective of whether you are here for x yrs or y months or z days and can give his/her opinion .... does being here for x years give a Ist class upgrade in an airline or something like that?
2ndly, discussing 4th or 5th 11 makes little sense, imo, and thats what i m saying and not stoping anyone to discuss this
anyways, how abt a high calibre analysis of 11th eleven of some country
Snuffed it.1. Hilditch
In some ways, it's very difficult to say. For the most part, the internationals don't play in the domestic championships (although has began to change recently) and when they do, they tend to struggle - with the poor pitches, presumably, especialy with the batsmen. 400 tends to be a massive score and pitches degenerate very quickly, so that it's difficult to judge whether a spinner has bowled well or not.So how do the Bang 4th/5ths look? Is there any depth or are these guys a league below 1sts/2nds.
EDIT: RetractedAs for India. 3rds look strong. Interesting to see Sreesanth in the thirds as statistically he is the best Indian bowler in history. Obviously that doesnt mean much apart from Indian cricket is pretty deep ATM.
Ahead of Chawla? Probably just an oversight.3rd XI
1. Dhawan
2. Rahane
3. Amol Muzumdar
4. Pujara
5. M Tiwary
6. Raina
7. Manhas (wk)
8. Amit Mishra
9. Pankaj Singh
10. Praveen Kumar
11. VRV Singh
Yes, edited.Ahead of Chawla? Probably just an oversight.