KP : 88 Matches, 7076 @ 49.48, 21 tons
GS : 102 Matches, email@example.com, 25 tons
I'd say it's very close and I might just lean more towards Smith because of his propensity to play well under pressure. He is an absolute monster when the pressure is on, even better than the much heralded VVS Laxman in that regard. And who can forget his temerity to walk out with a broken hand and confront the vicious Australian attack?