Poll to follow.
Think it's fair to say that Broad, after appearing to have turned the corner in 2009/10, has been majorly unconvincing this series. He seems completely unable to take wickets at the moment - and whilst he's had 2 fairly serious injuries in the last 6 months he needs to go back to county cricket and get some wickets under his belt. Shame there's pretty much no Championship cricket between now and the first Test.
Personally I'd go with Bresnan if he's fit - a huge hallmark of our success in Melbourne and Sydney was Bresnan keeping things tight as **** and almost boring the Aussies out - I reckon we'll need to adopt similar tactics at times to a batting lineup as powerful as India's this summer. Although Finn takes wickets, he doesn't build pressure the way Bresnan does.