What I get from the predictor is that the SA-Ind series seems to be the pivotal series as far as predicting a #1 ranking change goes. Even India losing to Australia 0-2 doesn't affect us as much as losing that one does, provided the remaining series' play as they should (IMO).
Anyone watching sky at the moment?
Think I agree with Nasser's squad.
Both him and Athers picking Tremlett.
Nas and Athers squads on Sky:
For me, I'd go for the combo and have Rashid and Shazhad.
Watto very adamant in that interview that he wants to open. I wonder if he feels that he has to try to set his stall out because the selectors might move him, or whether it was just an attempt to be confident about opening.
Think I agree with f_o_s. Monty's figures suggest he's bowled well, but Rashid is the more rounded cricketer. If Swanneh treads on a bar of soap on the morning of a test I'd be happier to see Rashid coming in. A 9-10-11 of Anderson-Finn-Panesar would be scary.
Also gives us the option of 5 bowlers if the situation merits it too.
Don't think Bres's bowling has quite enough about it in tests either, so Shahzad with his reverse swing the better option.
- As featured in The Independent.
"Even when England lost 5-0 in 2006-07 I don't remember them folding like this. This is as bad as I have seen from an England side."
- Mick Vaughan on the 2013/14 tourists' efforts
The idea of a young English leg spinner making his Test debut in an Ashes Test in Australia is a seriously worrying prospect - he might succeed I suppose, but I suspect its much more likely that after his first spell it'll be 0-50 in four overs and hiding in the outfield for the rest of the game - I'd take Monty as second spinner (well actually given a free hand I'd take Gary Keedy but there's no way that will happen with the selecors we have)
Yeah agree with Brumby about that lower order and about the importance of Rashid's batting. England may be regretting not having blooded Rashid in Test cricket before now. I imagine they reckoned he wouldn't be ready for this Ashes series come what may; and if so that might mean that they won't pick him now.
I'd be reluctant to get carried away with Monty's performance this season. He did ok but in truth he was far from outstanding in a far from outstanding Sussex bowling side which feasted on some inept batting in Div 2 and which without exception managed to achieve some pretty remarkable bowling stats.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)