| Player | Figures | Match Name |
| Jerome Taylor | 10-0-48-5 | West Indies in Zimbabwe: 4th match, 2007/08 |
| Fidel Edwards | 10-0-45-5 | NatWest Series: 1st ODI, 2007 |
| Dwayne Smith | 10-0-45-5 | West Indies in New Zealand: 5th ODI, 2005/06 |
| Pedro Collins | 10-1-43-5 | VB Series: 6th Match, 2004/05 |
| Mervyn Dillon | 10-4-29-5 | ICC Champions Trophy: 8th Match, 2004 |
| Fidel Edwards | 7-1-22-6 | West Indies in Zimbabwe: 4th ODI, 2003/04 |
| Chris Gayle | 10-0-46-5 | Australia in West Indies: 7th ODI, 2002/03 |
| Vasbert Drakes | 10-2-33-5 | ICC World Cup: 42nd Match, 2002/03 |
| Vasbert Drakes | 9.5-1-44-5 | ICC World Cup: 24th Match, 2002/03 |
| Mervyn Dillon | 10-1-52-5 | India in West Indies: 5th ODI, 2001/02 |
| Corey Collymore | 9.2-0-51-5 | LG Abans Triangular Series: 3rd Match, 2001/02 |
| Colin Stuart | 10-1-44-5 | West Indies in Kenya: 1st ODI, 2001 |
| Franklyn Rose | 10-1-23-5 | Cable & Wireless One Day International Series: 4th Match, 1999/00 |
| Mervyn Dillon | 10-1-51-5 | DMC Cup: 3rd ODI, 1999 |
| Jimmy Adams | 10-0-37-5 | Carlton & United Series: 4th Match, 1996/97 |
| Ottis Gibson | 10-1-40-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 11th Match, 1995/96 |
| Ottis Gibson | 8.4-0-42-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 6th Match, 1995/96 |
| Winston Benjamin | 10-3-22-5 | C.A.B. Jubilee Tournament (Hero Cup): 2nd Match, 1993/94 |
| Curtly Ambrose | 9.3-2-32-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 1st Final, 1992/93 |
| Ian Bishop | 8.4-0-25-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 9th Match, 1992/93 |
| Andy Cummins | 9.3-1-31-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 9th Match, 1991/92 |
| Curtly Ambrose | 10-1-53-5 | Wills Trophy: 4th Match, 1991/92 |
| Tony Gray | 9-0-50-6 | West Indies v Australia: 2nd ODI, 1990/91 |
| Sir Viv Richards | 9.4-0-41-6 | MRF World Series (Nehru Cup): 8th Match, 1989/90 |
| Curtly Ambrose | 10-2-26-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 1st Final, 1988/89 |
| Ian Bishop | 10-1-27-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 6th Match, 1988/89 |
| Curtly Ambrose | 8.2-1-17-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series: 4th Match, 1988/89 |
| Patrick Patterson | 9.4-0-29-6 | India v West Indies: 1st ODI, 1987/88 |
| Sir Viv Richards | 10-0-41-5 | New Zealand v West Indies: 1st ODI, 1986/87 |
| Joel Garner | 10-0-47-5 | Benson & Hedges Challenge: 4th Match, 1986/87 |
| Courtney Walsh | 4.3-3-1-5 | Champions Trophy: 5th Match, 1986/87 |
| Michael Holding | 10-1-26-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series Cup: 3rd Final, 1984/85 |
| Joel Garner | 10-1-31-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series Cup: 3rd Final, 1983/84 |
| Winston Davis | 10.3-0-51-7 | Prudential World Cup: 7th Match, 1983 |
| Colin Croft | 9-4-15-6 | West Indies v England: 1st ODI, 1980/81 |
| Andy Roberts | 10-5-22-5 | Benson & Hedges World Series Cup: 11th Match, 1979/80 |
| Joel Garner | 11-0-38-5 | Prudential World Cup: Only Final, 1979 |
| Vanburn Holder | 10-0-50-5 | Prudential Trophy: 3rd ODI, 1976 |
