CW decides another one, the greatest All-Rounder ever. 32 players, Nomination thread!

[jaideep]

Chris Gayle
Brian McMillan
Carl Hooper

 

[mr_mister]

Imran
Hadlee
Sobers
Botham
Miller
Kallis
Procter
Mankad
Flintoff
Grace
Kapil
Wilfred Rhodes
S Pollock
Chris Cairns
Dan Vettori
Klusener
Greig
Wasim
Shane Watson
Heath Streak
Shakib Al Hasan
Aubrey Faulkner
Clive Rice
Gilbert Jessop
Sanath Jayasuriya
Learie Constantine
Shahid Afridi
Monty Noble
Armstrong
Goddard
Mustaq Mohammad
Richie Benaud
Hammond
Ashwin
Bravo
Oram
Ryan ten Doeschate
Steve Tikolo
Angelo Mathews
Hafeez
Duminy
Maurice Tate
Alec Bedser
Ekanth Solkar
Symonds
Harper
Razzaq
Azhar Mahmood
Neil Johnson
Frank Woolley
George Giffen
John Reid
Frank Foster
Davidson
Trevor Bailey
Gubby
Steve Waugh
Chris Harris
Chaminda Vaas


59 in, 5 more to go. Choose carefully

 

[mr_mister]

i'm kinda iffy on Roger Harper... out of these modern west indies All rounders who is the most deserving, and are any deserving?

Harper
Arthurton
Simmons
Gayle
Sammy
Pollard
Russell
Holder

 

[mr_mister]

also what about Phil De Freitas >_>

 

[jaideep]

also what about Phil De Freitas >_>

No

 

[mr_mister]

haha, it was a half-joke. Yeah Hooper is a good choice.

Surely Astle in before McMillian right?

 

[Noble One]

Arthurton

We might as well start considering Chanderpauls leg breaks.

 

[jaideep]

i'm kinda iffy on Roger Harper... out of these modern west indies All rounders who is the most deserving, and are any deserving?

Harper
Arthurton
Simmons
Gayle
Sammy
Pollard
Russell
Holder

Frank Worell,Gayle,Hooper and Brian McMillan.

 

[mr_mister]

i think i just really like his name

Does Bev deserve a shot if its being expanded to 64?

What about Malcolm Marshall, Johnson and Warne?

 

[jaideep]

haha, it was a half-joke. Yeah Hooper is a good choice.

Surely Astle in before McMillian right?

My bad.Brian McMillan not Craig.

 

[mr_mister]

oh of course Brian McMillan! A must-have

 

[mr_mister]

what about renowned opening bowler Stan McCabe

 

[mr_mister]

i think we're catering way more to batsmen who occasionally tossed down a few offies than the frontline bowlers who were solid batsmen

 

[jaideep]

what about renowned opening bowler Stan McCabe

No.I think we are upto 64.

 

[Howe_zat]

Bill Edrich if we're going this way

 

[fredfertang]

Ronnie Irani ..................................

 

[Lillian Thomson]

According to Ian Botham Mike Brearley told him before the start of the Pakistan Tour in 1977/78 that he considered Chris Old to be the number 1 all-rounder in the party.

 

[The Sean]

Did Jack Gregory end up making this? If not GET HIM IN THERE!

 

[The Sean]

And if we're still short - Charlie Kelleway and Ravi Shastri.

 

[marc71178]

it's funny I feel Vettori's bowling will let him down more than his batting when the voting starts

His general meh-ness will be the biggest problem.

Then again, as the original 32 which was already difficult enough to reach without including lots of meh is being extended to 64 then there's scope for pretty much anyone who once took a wicket it seems.