As i debated with you before, you are placing too much emphasis on the stats in List A cricket.
That is historically proven to be very poor guide to judging how players may go in ODI cricket for ENG.
Using the
2009 OD averages that you got those stats from. Look at James Foster, he has a SR rate of 112, with 15 sixes. Now surely you are not going to tell me, Foster is capable of replicating that in ODI cricket now?.
At the end of the day i'm not forcing my view on anyone. Forgetting what the averages say, what i've seen of Davies & Kiewsetter on TV. IF in the future ENG want an ODI & T20 keeper to bat up the order (which is up for debate), Kiewsetter if picked is the more natural hitter & he is more likely to replicate that at ODI level IMO.