ah ok, i guess that cant be used as an excuse when he signs for the roosters in july next year...Blewy said:Reason being, Benji is good mates with Todd Payten who lives with Minnichello and a couple of the other guys, there were actually a few Tigers guys there...
broncoman said:i think you need a fullback too, not only is it pathetic you have brent webb there, hes not even a kiwi! surely theres a player in the batercard cup better than him!
no i didnt mean it like that, i mean it like, if they could get a non kiwi to play fullback for their national team, 3 years ago they should have actually recruited someone decent.... if you understand that....Mister Wright said:That's a bit hipocritical there Simon. You were praising Tonie Carroll's selection for Australia - he isn't Australian.
broncoman said:no i didnt mean it like that, i mean it like, if they could get a non kiwi to play fullback for their national team, 3 years ago they should have actually recruited someone decent.... if you understand that....
broncoman said:still doesnt my opinion that Brent Webb is so very very average...
Tim said:There is nobody better in the Bartercard Cup because all the good players have been raided by Australian & English Clubs.
These players get taken by overseas clubs at the ages of 14 & 15..so by the time they get to club football level in 3 or 4 years they switch their allegiance to Australia or Great Britain. Or in some cases, the State of Origin carrot get dangled infront of them.
It's the exact same problem that the Pacific Islands have with the All Blacks...all the riches get plundered.
So if you want to keep playing a very very average NZ team then so be it...i've got no time for international rugby league until certain administrations get the priorities right.
It has nothing to do with the Australian clubs, I have not heard of any cases where they have stopped players from playing International League for New Zealand. Maybe you should be accusing the players and not clubs.Tim said:It's a case of money & greed if you ask me.
The NZRL have absolutely nothing on the ARL when it comes to money & offering representitive football.
If international league was stronger then players might resist the temptation to play State of Origin..but as it is, State of Origin is regarded better so more players aspire to that.
Let's not forget that these players are usually around 17 or 18 when they're having to make these decisions. Sometimes I think 'pride' is at the back of their mind..and it's more about how much they can earn & whats best for their future.
You obviously haven't watched much of Benji, He has created plenty of opportunities in the games he has played... He almost single handedly carved Canberra up the 1st time we played them this year...thewizard1o1 said:Hopefully the fact that SBW has decided to stick with New Zealand will start changeing the minds of other young Kiwis, cause at the moment international league sucks balls.
On Benji, i don't think he is the type of player that you need at 5/8 since so far he has shown very little team play, sure he is a great attacker in his own right but i have yet to see him create many chances for the players around him.