Well i guess it depends what test batsmen you're comparing him to, because in the test series he only scored one run less than Gambir!!, imo a player should be judged on their age and experience aswell as their performance, holding Kraigg at the same standard as a Sehwag isn't fair because both are at different stages of their careers, for me getting three 50s in four tests is decent enough, "poor" is doing what Hughes did in the recent tests vs NZ i think, and yet he's got tons to his name against SA,
As for Gayle, he's done!!..can't see him coming back at all, and although people love to blame the board the fact is Gayle cares more about getting paid big bucks in the T20s than playing for WI right now, which is why Brathwaite and Barath are being put together so they can build a partnership for now and the future,
Anyway you think your lot has a chance in the Caribbean? personally i don't think so, but i guess we'll have to wait and see!!
.