• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

All-Time England XIs - A re-run

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
Jofra Archer - 3
Tim Bresnan - 2

Brian Close - 5

David Lloyd - 4
Rory Burns - 3

Frederick Fane - 2
Paul Gibb - 1

Clive Radley - 4
Billy Gunn - 4

Peter Willey - 1
Dawid Mallan - 1
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
England XIEngland AEngland BEngland C
1. JB Hobbs1. H Sutcliffe1. AN Cook1. JH Edrich
2. L Hutton*2. G Boycott2. GA Gooch2. DL Amiss ⬆
3. WG Grace ⬆3. KF Barrington ⬇3. KS Ranjitsinhji ⬇3. A Shrewsbury* ⬆⬆
4. WR Hammond4. PBH May*4. DI Gower4. KP Pietersen ⬇
5. JE Root ⬆5. DS Compton ⬇5. MC Cowdrey ⬆5. EH Hendren
6. IT Botham6. BA Stokes ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆6. ER Dexter*6. FE Woolley ⬇
7. APE Knott+7. LEG Ames+7. MW Tate7. MJ Prior+ ⬆⬆⬆⬆
8. JC Laker8. H Verity8. TG Evans+8. W Rhodes
9. FS Trueman9. H Larwood ⬇9. JA Snow ⬇9. SCJ Broad ⬆
10. JM Anderson ⬆⬆10. AV Bedser10. RGD Willis10. GA Lohmann
11. SF Barnes11. JB Statham ⬆⬆11. DL Underwood11. FH Tyson ⬇⬇
England DEngland E England FEngland G
1. ME Trescothick ⬇1. AC Maclaren1. MA Atherton ⬆1. AJ Strauss
2. C Washbrook ⬆⬆2. TW Hayward ⬆⬆2. MP Vaughan*2. R Abel ⬆
3. GP Thorpe ⬇3. TW Graveney ⬇3. IJL Trott ⬇3. RA Smith ⬇
4. CB Fry ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆4. E Paynter4. CP Mead ⬇4. KS Duleepsinhji ⬇
5. M Leyland5. FS Jackson ⬇5. H Brook ✴5. DR Jardine* ⬇
6. AJ Stewart+*6. AW Greig* ⬇6. AG Steel ⬆⬆6. BL D'Oliveira
7. A Flintoff ⬇7. RC Russell+ ⬇⬇7. JM Parks+7. JM Bairstow+ ⬇⬇
8. GP Swann ⬆8. FR Foster ⬇8. WH Lockwood8. CR Woakes ✴
9. JH Wardle9. R Peel ⬆9. AR Caddick ⬆⬆9. JH Briggs
10. D Gough ⬇10. ARC Fraser10. W Voce ⬇10. R Appleyard ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆
11. T Richardson11. WE Bowes11. C Blythe ⬆⬆11. K Farnes ⬇
England HEngland IEngland JEngland K
1. BC Broad ⬆1. BM Duckett ✴1. PE Richardson ⬇⬇1. C Milburn
2. CAG Russell ⬆⬆⬆2. A Sandham ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆2. G Pullar2. R Subba Row ⬇⬇
3. WJ Edrich ⬇⬇3. JT Tyldesly ⬇3. AE Stoddart3. G Gunn ⬇⬇
4. AJ Lamb4. GE Tyldesly ⬇⬇4. N Hussein* ⬇4. MK Gatting* ⬇
5. IR Bell5. J Hardstaff Jr ⬇⬇5. KWR Fletcher5. PD Collingwood ⬇
6. TE Bailey ⬇⬇⬇6. G Ulyett ⬆⬆6. W Bates6. JC Buttler+ ✴
7. GH Hirst ⬇7. W Barnes ⬇7. BT Foakes+ ✴7. MM Ali ✴
8. GO Allen* ⬇⬇8. AFA Lilley+ ⬆8. MS Nichols ✴8. RWV Robbins ⬆
9. RW Taylor+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇9. FJ Titmus* ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆9. CM Old ⬇9. M Hendrick ⬇⬇
10. MJ Hoggard10. DJ Brown ⬇⬇10. AP Freeman ⬆10. PJ Loader ⬇
11. GAR Lock ⬆⬆11. SJ Harmison11. K Higgs ⬇⬇⬇11. JT Hearne ⬆
England LEngland MEngland NEngland O
1. JDB Robertson ⬆1. CF Walter ⬇1. BW Luckhurst ⬆1. RT Robinson
2. PF Warner ✴2. RW Barber ⬇2. CJ Barnett ⬇2. G Fowler ⬇
3. DS Sheppard ⬇3. MA Butcher ⬇3. RES Wyatt ⬇3. RT Simpson ⬇⬇
4. PH Parfitt ⬇⬇⬇4. MH Denness* ⬇⬇4. RH Spooner ⬇⬇4. MJK Smith ⬇⬇
5. GA Hick5. RE Foster ⬆5. DW Randall ⬇⬇⬇5. GS Ballance ✴
6. JL Smith+ ✴6. GL Jessop ⬆⬆6. OJD Pope+ ✴6. FR Brown* ⬇⬇
7. JWHT Douglas*7. DA Allen ⬆7. R Illingworth* ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇7. GO Jones+ ⬇⬇
8. DG Cork ⬇8. JT Murray+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇8. BR Knight ⬇⬇⬇8. JN Crawford ✴
9. OE Robinson ✴9. GR Dilley ⬇⬇⬇9. JC White ✴9. AS Kennedy ✴
10. JK Lever10. SP Jones10. GG Arnold ⬇⬇⬇10. M Wood ✴
11. R Tattersall ✴11. HL Jackson ✴11. A Shaw ✴11. RJ Sidebottom ⬇⬇⬇
England PEngland Q England R
1. Z Crawley ✴1. CJ Tavaré ✴1. D Lloyd ✴
2. RG Barlow ✴2. AH Bakewell ✴2. RJ Burns ✴
3. DS Steele ✴3. PJ Sharpe ⬇⬇3. CT Radley ⬇⬇⬇⬇
4. WW Read* ⬇⬇4. JC Crawley ✴4. W Gunn ⬇⬇⬇
5. AJ Watkins ⬇5. MR Ramprakash ✴5.
6. RA Woolmer ⬇⬇6. DB Close* ✴6.
7. G Miller ✴7. CMW Read+ ✴7.
8. AAP Atkinson ✴8. G Geary ⬇⬇⬇8.
9. GH Duckworth+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇9. JC Archer ✴9.
10. ST Finn ⬇10. E Peate ✴10.
11. DW Headley ⬇⬇11. CT Tremlett ⬇⬇⬇⬇11.
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
England XIEngland AEngland BEngland C
1. JB Hobbs1. H Sutcliffe1. AN Cook1. JH Edrich
2. L Hutton*2. G Boycott2. GA Gooch2. DL Amiss ⬆
3. WG Grace ⬆3. KF Barrington ⬇3. KS Ranjitsinhji ⬇3. A Shrewsbury* ⬆⬆
4. WR Hammond4. PBH May*4. DI Gower4. KP Pietersen ⬇
5. JE Root ⬆5. DS Compton ⬇5. MC Cowdrey ⬆5. EH Hendren
6. IT Botham6. BA Stokes ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆6. ER Dexter*6. FE Woolley ⬇
7. APE Knott+7. LEG Ames+7. MW Tate7. MJ Prior+ ⬆⬆⬆⬆
8. JC Laker8. H Verity8. TG Evans+8. W Rhodes
9. FS Trueman9. H Larwood ⬇9. JA Snow ⬇9. SCJ Broad ⬆
10. JM Anderson ⬆⬆10. AV Bedser10. RGD Willis10. GA Lohmann
11. SF Barnes11. JB Statham ⬆⬆11. DL Underwood11. FH Tyson ⬇⬇
England DEngland E England FEngland G
1. ME Trescothick ⬇1. AC Maclaren1. MA Atherton ⬆1. AJ Strauss
2. C Washbrook ⬆⬆2. TW Hayward ⬆⬆2. MP Vaughan*2. R Abel ⬆
3. GP Thorpe ⬇3. TW Graveney ⬇3. IJL Trott ⬇3. RA Smith ⬇
4. CB Fry ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆4. E Paynter4. CP Mead ⬇4. KS Duleepsinhji ⬇
5. M Leyland5. FS Jackson ⬇5. H Brook ✴5. DR Jardine* ⬇
6. AJ Stewart+*6. AW Greig* ⬇6. AG Steel ⬆⬆6. BL D'Oliveira
7. A Flintoff ⬇7. RC Russell+ ⬇⬇7. JM Parks+7. JM Bairstow+ ⬇⬇
8. GP Swann ⬆8. FR Foster ⬇8. WH Lockwood8. CR Woakes ✴
9. JH Wardle9. R Peel ⬆9. AR Caddick ⬆⬆9. JH Briggs
10. D Gough ⬇10. ARC Fraser10. W Voce ⬇10. R Appleyard ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆
11. T Richardson11. WE Bowes11. C Blythe ⬆⬆11. K Farnes ⬇
England HEngland IEngland JEngland K
1. BC Broad ⬆1. BM Duckett ✴1. PE Richardson ⬇⬇1. C Milburn
2. CAG Russell ⬆⬆⬆2. A Sandham ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆2. G Pullar2. R Subba Row ⬇⬇
3. WJ Edrich ⬇⬇3. JT Tyldesly ⬇3. AE Stoddart3. G Gunn ⬇⬇
4. AJ Lamb4. GE Tyldesly ⬇⬇4. N Hussein* ⬇4. MK Gatting* ⬇
5. IR Bell5. J Hardstaff Jr ⬇⬇5. KWR Fletcher5. PD Collingwood ⬇
6. TE Bailey ⬇⬇⬇6. G Ulyett ⬆⬆6. W Bates6. JC Buttler+ ✴
7. GH Hirst ⬇7. W Barnes ⬇7. BT Foakes+ ✴7. MM Ali ✴
8. GO Allen* ⬇⬇8. AFA Lilley+ ⬆8. MS Nichols ✴8. RWV Robbins ⬆
9. RW Taylor+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇9. FJ Titmus* ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆9. CM Old ⬇9. M Hendrick ⬇⬇
10. MJ Hoggard10. DJ Brown ⬇⬇10. AP Freeman ⬆10. PJ Loader ⬇
11. GAR Lock ⬆⬆11. SJ Harmison11. K Higgs ⬇⬇⬇11. JT Hearne ⬆
England LEngland MEngland NEngland O
1. JDB Robertson ⬆1. CF Walter ⬇1. BW Luckhurst ⬆1. RT Robinson
2. PF Warner ✴2. RW Barber ⬇2. CJ Barnett ⬇2. G Fowler ⬇
3. DS Sheppard ⬇3. MA Butcher ⬇3. RES Wyatt ⬇3. RT Simpson ⬇⬇
4. PH Parfitt ⬇⬇⬇4. MH Denness* ⬇⬇4. RH Spooner ⬇⬇4. MJK Smith ⬇⬇
5. GA Hick5. RE Foster ⬆5. DW Randall ⬇⬇⬇5. GS Ballance ✴
6. JL Smith+ ✴6. GL Jessop ⬆⬆6. OJD Pope+ ✴6. FR Brown* ⬇⬇
7. JWHT Douglas*7. DA Allen ⬆7. R Illingworth* ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇7. GO Jones+ ⬇⬇
8. DG Cork ⬇8. JT Murray+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇8. BR Knight ⬇⬇⬇8. JN Crawford ✴
9. OE Robinson ✴9. GR Dilley ⬇⬇⬇9. JC White ✴9. AS Kennedy ✴
10. JK Lever10. SP Jones10. GG Arnold ⬇⬇⬇10. M Wood ✴
11. R Tattersall ✴11. HL Jackson ✴11. A Shaw ✴11. RJ Sidebottom ⬇⬇⬇
England PEngland Q England R
1. Z Crawley ✴1. CJ Tavaré ✴1. D Lloyd ✴
2. RG Barlow ✴2. AH Bakewell ✴2. RJ Burns ✴
3. DS Steele ✴3. PJ Sharpe ⬇⬇3. CT Radley ⬇⬇⬇⬇
4. WW Read* ⬇⬇4. JC Crawley ✴4. W Gunn ⬇⬇⬇
5. AJ Watkins ⬇5. MR Ramprakash ✴5.
6. RA Woolmer ⬇⬇6. DB Close* ✴6.
7. G Miller ✴7. CMW Read+ ✴7. JS Foster+ ✴
8. AAP Atkinson ✴8. G Geary ⬇⬇⬇8. TT Bresnan ✴
9. GH Duckworth+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇9. JC Archer ✴9. MJ Leach ✴
10. ST Finn ⬇10. E Peate ✴10.
11. DW Headley ⬇⬇11. CT Tremlett ⬇⬇⬇⬇11. NAT Foster ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
Now, to wrap things up with England, please vote for:
A) A middle order batsman
B) A player to bat at 6
C) Another bowler
D) The captain of England R
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
JW Hearne
Len Braund (think both are about as good as batsman available and together provide some wonderful bowling depth)

William Attewell

Rory Burns
 
Last edited:

Coronis

Hall of Fame Member
@capt_Luffy its nothing against you personally or the wonderful effort you’ve put in. I just find All X XIs pretty meaningless after a certain point. Like this is what, 19 XIs so basically a third of all English players get in. And like, pretty much everyone who’s played 15+ matches. Just stops being appealing at a point for me.
 

Top