• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

All-Time England XIs - A re-run

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
@capt_Luffy its nothing against you personally or the wonderful effort you’ve put in. I just find All X XIs pretty meaningless after a certain point. Like this is what, 19 XIs so basically a third of all English players get in. And like, pretty much everyone who’s played 15+ matches. Just stops being appealing at a point for me.
I get that, but also kinda don't really. How shall I put it, even in this team players like Tim Bresnan (26 bat, 32 ball, 23m) are just making it. We always fawn over the Greats, I feel sometimes those who were kinda mid but served their countries well (Foster, DeFreitas, etc) deserved respect as well.
 

Northerner

U19 12th Man
I get that, but also kinda don't really. How shall I put it, even in this team players like Tim Bresnan (26 bat, 32 ball, 23m) are just making it. We always fawn over the Greats, I feel sometimes those who were kinda mid but served their countries well (Foster, DeFreitas, etc) deserved respect as well.
Agreed, players like Norman Cowans. Chris Lewis at times where class but not consistent enough, Paul Jarvis could have had a long test career if he had not gone on the rebel tour, he had genuine pace,
 
Last edited:

kyear2

Hall of Fame Member
@capt_Luffy its nothing against you personally or the wonderful effort you’ve put in. I just find All X XIs pretty meaningless after a certain point. Like this is what, 19 XIs so basically a third of all English players get in. And like, pretty much everyone who’s played 15+ matches. Just stops being appealing at a point for me.
+1
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
'Young Jack' Hearne - 4
Peter Willey - 2

Len Braund - 6

Phil DeFreitas - 4

William Attewell - 1
Tom Cartwright - 1

Billy Gunn - 3
Rory Burns - 1
Clive Radley - 1
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
England XIEngland AEngland BEngland C
1. JB Hobbs1. H Sutcliffe1. AN Cook1. JH Edrich
2. L Hutton*2. G Boycott2. GA Gooch2. DL Amiss ⬆
3. WG Grace ⬆3. KF Barrington ⬇3. KS Ranjitsinhji ⬇3. A Shrewsbury* ⬆⬆
4. WR Hammond4. PBH May*4. DI Gower4. KP Pietersen ⬇
5. JE Root ⬆5. DS Compton ⬇5. MC Cowdrey ⬆5. EH Hendren
6. IT Botham6. BA Stokes ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆6. ER Dexter*6. FE Woolley ⬇
7. APE Knott+7. LEG Ames+7. MW Tate7. MJ Prior+ ⬆⬆⬆⬆
8. JC Laker8. H Verity8. TG Evans+8. W Rhodes
9. FS Trueman9. H Larwood ⬇9. JA Snow ⬇9. SCJ Broad ⬆
10. JM Anderson ⬆⬆10. AV Bedser10. RGD Willis10. GA Lohmann
11. SF Barnes11. JB Statham ⬆⬆11. DL Underwood11. FH Tyson ⬇⬇
England DEngland E England FEngland G
1. ME Trescothick ⬇1. AC Maclaren1. MA Atherton ⬆1. AJ Strauss
2. C Washbrook ⬆⬆2. TW Hayward ⬆⬆2. MP Vaughan*2. R Abel ⬆
3. GP Thorpe ⬇3. TW Graveney ⬇3. IJL Trott ⬇3. RA Smith ⬇
4. CB Fry ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆4. E Paynter4. CP Mead ⬇4. KS Duleepsinhji ⬇
5. M Leyland5. FS Jackson ⬇5. H Brook ✴5. DR Jardine* ⬇
6. AJ Stewart+*6. AW Greig* ⬇6. AG Steel ⬆⬆6. BL D'Oliveira
7. A Flintoff ⬇7. RC Russell+ ⬇⬇7. JM Parks+7. JM Bairstow+ ⬇⬇
8. GP Swann ⬆8. FR Foster ⬇8. WH Lockwood8. CR Woakes ✴
9. JH Wardle9. R Peel ⬆9. AR Caddick ⬆⬆9. JH Briggs
10. D Gough ⬇10. ARC Fraser10. W Voce ⬇10. R Appleyard ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆
11. T Richardson11. WE Bowes11. C Blythe ⬆⬆11. K Farnes ⬇
England HEngland IEngland JEngland K
1. BC Broad ⬆1. BM Duckett ✴1. PE Richardson ⬇⬇1. C Milburn
2. CAG Russell ⬆⬆⬆2. A Sandham ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆2. G Pullar2. R Subba Row ⬇⬇
3. WJ Edrich ⬇⬇3. JT Tyldesly ⬇3. AE Stoddart3. G Gunn ⬇⬇
4. AJ Lamb4. GE Tyldesly ⬇⬇4. N Hussein* ⬇4. MK Gatting* ⬇
5. IR Bell5. J Hardstaff Jr ⬇⬇5. KWR Fletcher5. PD Collingwood ⬇
6. TE Bailey ⬇⬇⬇6. G Ulyett ⬆⬆6. W Bates6. JC Buttler+ ✴
7. GH Hirst ⬇7. W Barnes ⬇7. BT Foakes+ ✴7. MM Ali ✴
8. GO Allen* ⬇⬇8. AFA Lilley+ ⬆8. MS Nichols ✴8. RWV Robbins ⬆
9. RW Taylor+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇9. FJ Titmus* ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆9. CM Old ⬇9. M Hendrick ⬇⬇
10. MJ Hoggard10. DJ Brown ⬇⬇10. AP Freeman ⬆10. PJ Loader ⬇
11. GAR Lock ⬆⬆11. SJ Harmison11. K Higgs ⬇⬇⬇11. JT Hearne ⬆
England LEngland MEngland NEngland O
1. JDB Robertson ⬆1. CF Walter ⬇1. BW Luckhurst ⬆1. RT Robinson
2. PF Warner ✴2. RW Barber ⬇2. CJ Barnett ⬇2. G Fowler ⬇
3. DS Sheppard ⬇3. MA Butcher ⬇3. RES Wyatt ⬇3. RT Simpson ⬇⬇
4. PH Parfitt ⬇⬇⬇4. MH Denness* ⬇⬇4. RH Spooner ⬇⬇4. MJK Smith ⬇⬇
5. GA Hick5. RE Foster ⬆5. DW Randall ⬇⬇⬇5. GS Ballance ✴
6. JL Smith+ ✴6. GL Jessop ⬆⬆6. OJD Pope+ ✴6. FR Brown* ⬇⬇
7. JWHT Douglas*7. DA Allen ⬆7. R Illingworth* ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇7. GO Jones+ ⬇⬇
8. DG Cork ⬇8. JT Murray+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇8. BR Knight ⬇⬇⬇8. JN Crawford ✴
9. OE Robinson ✴9. GR Dilley ⬇⬇⬇9. JC White ✴9. AS Kennedy ✴
10. JK Lever10. SP Jones10. GG Arnold ⬇⬇⬇10. M Wood ✴
11. R Tattersall ✴11. HL Jackson ✴11. A Shaw ✴11. RJ Sidebottom ⬇⬇⬇
England PEngland Q England R
1. Z Crawley ✴1. CJ Tavaré ✴1. D Lloyd ✴
2. RG Barlow ✴2. AH Bakewell ✴2. RJ Burns ✴
3. DS Steele ✴3. PJ Sharpe ⬇⬇3. CT Radley ⬇⬇⬇⬇
4. WW Read* ⬇⬇4. JC Crawley ✴4. W Gunn* ⬇⬇⬇
5. AJ Watkins ⬇5. MR Ramprakash ✴5. JW Hearne ✴
6. RA Woolmer ⬇⬇6. DB Close* ✴6. LC Braund ✴
7. G Miller ✴7. CMW Read+ ✴7. JS Foster+ ✴
8. AAP Atkinson ✴8. G Geary ⬇⬇⬇8. TT Bresnan ✴
9. GH Duckworth+ ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇9. JC Archer ✴9. PAJ DeFreitas ⬇⬇⬇⬇
10. ST Finn ⬇10. E Peate ✴10. MJ Leach ✴
11. DW Headley ⬇⬇11. CT Tremlett ⬇⬇⬇⬇11. NAT Foster ⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇
 

sayon basak

Cricketer Of The Year
I get that, but also kinda don't really. How shall I put it, even in this team players like Tim Bresnan (26 bat, 32 ball, 23m) are just making it. We always fawn over the Greats, I feel sometimes those who were kinda mid but served their countries well (Foster, DeFreitas, etc) deserved respect as well.
Young Jack is better than half of the players here.
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
England XIEngland AEngland BEngland CEngland D
1. Jack Hobbs1. Herbert Sutcliffe 1. Alaistar Cook 1. John Edrich 1. Marcus Trescothick
2. Len Hutton*2. Geoff Boycott 2. Graham Gooch2. Dennis Amiss 2. Cyril Washbrook
3. WG Grace3. Ken Barrington 3. KS Ranjitsinhji 3. Arthur Shrewsbury* 3. Graham Thorpe
4. Wally Hammond4. Peter May*4. David Gower4. Kevin Pietersen 4. CB Fry
5. Joe Root 5. Denis Compton 5. Colin Cowdrey 5. Patsy Hendren 5. Maurice Leyland
6. Ian Botham 6. Ben Stokes6. Ted Dexter*6. Frank Woolley 6. Alec Stewart+*
7. Allan Knott+7. Les Ames+7. Maurice Tate 7. Matt Prior+7. Andrew Flintoff
8. Jim Laker 8. Hedley Verity 8. Godfrey Evans+8. Wilfred Rhodes 8. Graeme Swann
9. Fred Trueman 9. Harold Larwood 9. John Snow 9. Stuart Broad 9. Johnny Wardle
10. James Anderson 10. Alec Bedser 10. Bob Willis 10. George Lohmann 10. Darren Gough
11. Sydney Barnes 11. Brian Statham 11. Derek Underwood 11. Frank Tyson 11. Tom Richardson
England EEngland FEngland GEngland HEngland I
1. Archie Maclaren 1. Mike Atherton 1. Andrew Strauss 1. Chris Broad1. Ben Duckett
2. Tom Hayward 2. Michael Vaughan*2. Bobby Abel 2. Jack Russell Sr2. Andy Sandham
3. Tom Graveney3. Jonathan Trott 3. Robin Smith 3. Bill Edrich 3. Johnny Tyldesly
4. Eddie Paynter4. Phil Mead 4. KS Duleepsinhji4. Allan Lamb4. Ernest Tyldesly
5. Stanley Jackson 5. Harry Brook 5. Douglas Jardine*5. Ian Bell 5. Joe Hardstaff Jr
6. Tony Greig*6. Allan Steel 6. Basil D'Oliveira 6. Trevor Bailey 6. George Ulyett
7. Jack Russell+7. Jim Parks Jr+7. Jonny Bairstow+7. George Hirst 7. Billy Barnes
8. Frank Foster8. Bill Lockwood8. Chris Woakes 8. Gubby Allen*8. Dick Lilley+
9. Bobby Peel 9. Bill Voce9. Johnny Briggs 9. Bob Taylor+9. Fred Titmus*
10. Angus Fraser 10. Andy Caddick10. Bob Appleyard 10. Tony Lock 10. David Brown
11. Bill Bowes 11. Colin Blythe 11. Ken Farnes 11. Matthew Hoggard11. Steve Harmison
England JEngland KEngland LEngland MEngland N
1. Peter Richardson1. Colin Milburn1. Jack Robertson1. Cyril Walters 1. Brian Luckhurst
2. Geoff Pullar 2. Raman Subba Row 2. Plum Warner2. Bob Barber2. Charlie Barnett
3. Andrew Stoddart 3. George Gunn3. David Sheppard 3. Mark Butcher3. Bob Wyatt
4. Nassir Hussain*4. Mike Gatting*4. Peter Parfitt4. Mike Denness*4. Reggie Spooner
5. Keith Fletcher 5. Paul Collingwood5. Graeme Hick 5. Tip Foster5. Derek Randall
6. Ben Foakes+6. Jos Buttler+6. Jamie Smith+6. Gilbert Jessop 6. Ollie Pope+
7. Billy Bates 7. Moeen Ali 7. Johnny Douglas*7. David Allen 7. Ray Illingworth*
8. Stan Nichols 8. Walter Robbins 8. Dominic Cork 8. John Murray+8. Barry Knight
9. Chris Old9. Mike Hendrick 9. Ollie Robinson9. Graham Dilley 9. Jack White
10. Tich Freeman10. Peter Loader 10. John Lever10. Simon Jones 10. Geoff Arnold
11. Ken Higgs 11. Jack Hearne 11. Roy Tattersall 11. Les Jackson 11. Alfred Shaw
England OEngland PEngland QEngland R
1. Tim Robinson1. Zak Crawley 1. Chris Tavaré1. David Lloyd
2. Graeme Fowler2. Dick Barlow 2. Fred Bakewell2. Rory Burns
3. Reg Simpson 3. David Steele 3. Phil Sharpe3. Clive Radley
4. Mike Smith 4. Walter Read*4. John Crawley 4. Billy Gunn*
5. Gary Ballance 5. Allan Watkins 5. Mark Ramprakash 5. 'Young Jack' Hearne
6. Freddie Brown*6. Bob Woolmer 6. Brian Close*6. Len Braund
7. Geraint Jones+7. Geoff Miller 7. Chris Read+7. James Foster+
8. Jack Crawford 8. Gus Atkinson 8. George Geary8. Tim Bresnan
9. Alex Kennedy 9. George Duckworth+9. Jofra Archer 9. Phil DeFreitas
10. Mark Wood 10. Steven Finn 10. Ted Peate 10. Jack Leach
11. Ryan Sidebottom 11. Dean Headley 11. Chris Tremlett 11. Neil Foster
 

Top