KiWiNiNjA
International Coach
Please don't use that slur.Even the Jap knew that one.

And I'm not Japanese, btw.
Please don't use that slur.Even the Jap knew that one.
addy?Going to throw my laptop out the window ftr.
You could give it to me instead, I need a new laptop.Going to throw my laptop out the window ftr.
Interestingly, about 2 months ago an umpire in Wellington cricket got the boot for calling a ball 'wide' when the batsman hit it to point.
8. Out from a Wide
When Wide ball has been called, neither batsman shall be out under any of the Laws except 33 (Handled the ball), 35 (Hit wicket), 37 (Obstructing the field), 38 (Run out) or 39 (Stumped).
© Marylebone Cricket Club 2003
The fact that Hussey hit it is irrelevant
If the ball has been called a wide, as that should have been, then quite simply, you cannot be out caught and it has happened in international cricket before (Akram vs Oz I believe a few years ago)
The fact that it doesnt make a lot of sense is pretty irrelevant
Way to pick and choose your laws, Social. You really are making a cretarded argument here.8. Out from a Wide
When Wide ball has been called, neither batsman shall be out under any of the Laws except 33 (Handled the ball), 35 (Hit wicket), 37 (Obstructing the field), 38 (Run out) or 39 (Stumped).
8. Out from a Wide
When Wide ball has been called, neither batsman shall be out under any of the Laws except 33 (Handled the ball), 35 (Hit wicket), 37 (Obstructing the field), 38 (Run out) or 39 (Stumped).
© Marylebone Cricket Club 2003
The fact that Hussey hit it is irrelevant
If the ball has been called a wide, as that should have been, then quite simply, you cannot be out caught and it has happened in international cricket before (Akram vs Oz I believe a few years ago)
The fact that it doesnt make a lot of sense is pretty irrelevant
Edit: Beaten, twice.Laws said:2. Delivery not a Wide
The umpire shall not adjudge a delivery as being a Wide
(a) if the striker, by moving,
either (i) causes the ball to pass wide of him, as defined in 1(b) above
or (ii) brings the ball sufficiently within his reach to be able to hit it with his bat by means of a normal cricket stroke.
(b) if the ball touches the striker's bat or person.
If it's a wide, you cant be out caught irrespective of whether you hit it
No doubt BCCI instituted that rule whilst social wasn't looking
No-one's saying he can get out off a wide. We're saying that it can't be a wide if he's deemed to have hit the ball.
Edit: Beaten, twice.