I forgot to give Bairstow a rating which I feel summarises his performance quite well
I forgot to give Bairstow a rating which I feel summarises his performance quite well
I didn't do the last match, but I'd like to mention Rogers innings on the first day which I thought almost changed the entire impetus of the series, didn't work out but was almost game-changing, anyway this match:
Rogers 8: gritty opener has really done a job for Oz
Warner 6: fine performance, needed to go on both times though, job half done
Khawaja 1: feel a bit sorry for him, hapless
Clarke 5: Really good pro-active captaincy, bowling too good for him
Smith 1: Honestly poor I'm guessing all his support is ironic.
Watto 6: really gritty top innings in the first dig, bowled okay in that too. injury meant he did nowt after.
Haddin 2: Didn't bat or keep well
Siddle 2: Really disappointing after some sterling performances
Harris 9: what a bowler, decent innings first up
Lyon 8: was the best spinner on show
Bird 3: don't want to do a FJ and dismiss him out of hand, but perfect conditions for his style of bowling, and he really wasn't good second go.
Cook 5: good 60 and he made some de4cent decisions in the last throes of the match
Root 2: not good really
Trott 5: scored 70 odd runs, not looking brilliant, took some good catches
KP 5: scored 80 odd good runs
Bell 9: Terrible first innings, second one was great though.
Bairstow 4: scored some runs fielded okay
Prior 1: batted terribly kept averagely
Broad 9: What a bowler what a man
Bresnan 8: bowled well, batted well
Swann 7: decent bowling, vital innings'
Anderson 2: not a great performance from him.
Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.
Rogers 9.5 - loses half a point for not getting a 50 second dig. World-class.
Warner 7 - almost put Australia in a winning position, if the middle order was stronger we would've won.
Khawaja 2 - looks abysmal.
Clarke 3.5 - captained well I guess. Did take a lot to get him out mind you.
Smith 1.5 - two failures, and dropped a catch.
Watson 6 - finally scores some important runs, but then gets out, and then injured. Oops.
Haddin 4 - kept well, did nothing with the bat though.
Siddle 2 - quiet. If this is another back-to-back test he probably should be rested.
Harris 9.5 - world-class, particularly in the second innings.
Lyon 8.5 - great performance. Maybe not Harris-esque but well deserved figures.
Bird 3.5 - mediocre. Imagine the **** Starc would get if he took Bird's figures.
Cook 5.5 - couple of starts.
Root 2 - err....stayed out there for a while.
Trott 5 - see Cook.
Pietersen 5.5 - useful knock in the second innings.
Bell 9 - nothing needs to be said about the first innings but was amazing in the second innings.
Bairstow 4 - fought hard I guess.
Prior 3 - horrid with the bat, OK with the gloves.
Bresnan 7 - crucial all-round contributions.
Broad 10 - wow.
Swann 7 - see Bresnan.
Anderson 5 - took some key wickets on the third morning, but looks out of sorts and arguably should be rested.
Want to be the online Don Bradman or Ian Salisbury?
Then join CW Cricket today. It's what all the cool kids desire.
RIP Craig Walsh (Craig) 1985-2012
RIP Hughesy 1988-2014
Khawaja 2 - looks abysmal.
It shouldn't of but this made me laugh, just so blunt and to the point.
Last edited by Cooky Monster; 12-08-2013 at 08:58 PM.
Abysmal really is a great word, just look at it, strange looking word but a brilliant word, still having a chuckle at it, heinous is the one i usually go for but abysmal is definately in from now on.
Thanks for that.
Only saw Khawaja's dismissal for the first time this morning. Kid looked like he was batting in Braille.
WWCC - Loyaulte Mi Lie
"Hope is the fuel of progress and fear is the prison in which you put yourself" - Tony Benn
#408. Sixty three not out forever.
Cook: 5/10 - Fifty in first innings + Good start in the second
Trott : 5/10 - ditto Cook
Pieterson : 6/10 - Important contribution in the second innings.
Bell: 9/10 - Match winning contribution #1 .
Bairstow : 4 - Batted okay in the second innings.
Prior : 3/10
Bresnan : 7.5/10 - Important second innings batting, gave England a total they could defend and also gave the ever important breakthrough
Broad : 10/10 - Match Winner #2 & overall best player of the match
Swann - 7.5/10 - Got two quick wickets on day 3 and good batting on day 4.
Anderson : 2/10 - Not great.
Rogers - 9/10 - Great show of grit on day 2, very good as well on day 4.
Warner - 7.5 - Bad first innings, a completely different animal in the second. Looked like he had taken the game away from England at one point
Khawaja - 0.5/10 - A bit of leniency here.
Clarke - 3 - Played a **** shot to get out first innings, was victim of a sizzling delivery in the second.
Smith - 2 - Looked good until he got out first innings, second was not that good
Watson - 5.5 - Played well enough in the first innings
Haddin - 5/10
Siddle - 3/10 - Uneventful
Harris : 9.5/10 - Like Broad, inspired respect among the batsmen by unleashing some seriously dangerous bowling.
Lyon - 7/10 - underrated and kept it tight often.
Bird - 4/10 - Decent start to his Ashes career I guess, but didn't look particularly fearsome.
Saw the dismissals and Uzi didn't look good but Smiths was very bad and Watson again.
Cook: 6 Getting starts but not going on. Throwing Bresnan the ball despite bellend Warne clamoring for Broad before he got Warner is brilliant.
Root: 3 Struggling hugely against the new ball. Big ? still remain about him as an opener.
Trott : 3 Sick of him getting himself out when he looks totally set and comfortable.
Pieterson : 6 Good runs in the 2nd innings that stalled the Aussies momentum.
Bell: 9 Yet again was quality. World class middle order bat.
Bairstow : 5 Was an important knock in the 2nd innings as it put us into the driving seat. He clearly has talent, but has looked so bad at times its scarcely believable.
Prior : 1 Nothing with the bat again and crap with the gloves again. Having a horror.
Bresnan : 8 Showed his value with the bat, and bowled pretty well first innings and excellently 2nd innings.
Broad : 10 11 wickets, and a couple of the best spells of bowling you can wish to see.
Swann - 7 Good with the bat, and took 4 important wickets.
Anderson : 3 Pretty poor with the ball for second game in a row.
Rogers: 9 Brilliant from Rogers, only loses a mark for getting out at quite crucial times. Just before the new ball first dig and just as he and Warner were really starting to get on top 2nd.
Warner: 8 Looked all at sea first innings but in the seconds he looked solid, watchful and powerful on anything loose.
Khawaja:1 Not a test match player. Hopeless against Swann.
Clarke: 2 Dreadful shot from a player of his class first innings and depite some lol comments otherwise got an unplayable one from Broad.
Smith: 2 Doesn't really look good enough, struggles against most of the bowlers. Only bright spot is he sometimes looks ok against Swann.
Watson: 6 Good innings first dig, but compounded the collapse by getting out LBW again.
Haddin: 3 Kept well but no runs.
Siddle: 2 Not very threatening with the ball.
Harris: 10 Brilliant in both innings, and a solid contribution with the bat to give Australia a lead.
Lyon: 6 Bowled well, kept it tight and bowled very few four balls. Didn't spin it and a fair few of his wickets were give aways but certainly he is a test quality spinner. No reason to be dropped.
Bird: 4 I thought he looked good first innings, but second innings he looked county standard. Something about him I like though.
I thought your ratings for England would have been:
Overall series ratings
Cook 5 - didn't score many but the ones he did score were important. Captaincy took a lot of stick but got the job done
Root 5 - struggled most of the time but played one gun innings and a couple of key wickets
Trott 4 - again struggled most of the time, played a few decent knocks where you'd have expected him to go on
Pietersen 6 - see above really, good knock at OT and a few decent starts, great knock tonight
Bell 9 - not much to say that hasn't already been said
Bairstow 3 - started to look composed in his last dig then got out, think he'll get another chance but needs to improve massively
Prior 3 - well below par, signs of improvement in the last Test hopefully point towards a better series in the return leg
Broad 8 - when he was good, he was incredible. Despite what his figures might have said he rarely fell apart bar the odd spell and played some useful knocks
Swann 8 - his best series against the Aussies, couldn't have asked for much more from him
Anderson 8 - ATG performance in one Test, very good in two and disappointing in the other two. The Anderson of 09 wouldn't have come back from his poor displays at OT/Durham though but there's no keeping him down
Finn 2 - woeful but did make the key breakthroughs in the first Aussie innings of the series for which we should all be grateful
Bresnan 8 - excellent with bat and ball, a real return to form, let's hope he's fit or the return leg
Kerrigan 9 - remained unbeaten in his only innings, a sterling effort
Woakes 5 - hard to rate, bowled erratically, looked decent with the bat on day 3 and in the chase tonight but was poor this morning
Rogers 8 - kept the new ball at bay so many times, probably a better series than his stats reflected
Watson 6 - woeful for three tests, decent at Durham, outstanding at The Oval
Cowan 2 - probably a better batsman than Khawaja
Clarke 6.5 - played the innings of the series but was unable to reach the heights he's scaled over the past few years the rest of the time, largely due to being Broad's bitch but also received some of the balls of the series
Smith 6 - great at The Oval, couple of other decent knocks, struggled the rest of the time
Hughes 5 - as bad as he was at Lord's, he kept a massacre at bay at Trent Bridge and probably deserves a bit more recognition for that
Haddin 7 - excellent with the gloves, did little with the bat post-TB
Siddle 7 - ran out of steam towards the end, falling just short overall for me of the standards set by Harris/Anderson/Broad
Starc 5 - a healthy mix of pies and jaffas keeps things interesting
Pattinson 5 - wasn't up to the standards we might have expected but he was evidently carrying an injury at least in the second Test, good with the bat
Agar 6 - the feel good story of the summer at TB but needs to learn to bowl
Khawaja 0 - makes Ravi Bopara look like Ricky Ponting
Harris 9 - deserved to be on the winning side
Warner 4 - cracking knock at Durham but little else of note for all his threat
Lyon 7 - showed that he should have been in from the start. If he got to bowl at Aussie's line-up then he could bump this up to an 8
Faulkner 8 - highly impressive on debut, if he'd lost his head tonight then the light may have been irrelevant
Have a feeling I've forgotten somebody, and as usual these are completely erratic and under no circumstances expected to be fair or balanced
I was going to do a full series one, but Oz have used so many players, I've forgotten half of them already.
Alastair Cook - 5 - Important second innings runs
Joe Root - 5 - Decent first innings fifty
Jonathan Trott - 7.5 - Decent match. Couple of minor scores, the latter really important in the run chase, and a wicket
Kevin Pietersen - 8 - Like Trott, but his second innings effort better
Ian Bell - 6 - Didn't even score a ton
Chris Woakes - 5 - Would've won it if the light held off for half an hour longer
Matt Prior - 6.5 - Decent forty odd and was tidy behind the sticks
Stuart Broad - 7.5 - Pretty good
Graeme Swann - 7 - Solid all-round mostly
James Anderson - 7 - See two above him
Simon Kerrigan - 1 - Feel for him really
David Warner - 2 - Couple of failures
Chris Rogers - 4 - Hung around in the first dig
Shane Watson - 9.5 - Fair play
Michael Clarke - 5 - Not much to say really
Steve Smith - 9 - WAFG
Brad Haddin - 4 - Bonus point for getting the record, which he loses for getting out to Trott
Forkers Faulkner - 8 - His selection was incredibly justified by almost everything he did happening in a one day like situation. The go to man in the chase
Mitchell Starc - 6 - OK I guess, still not sold on him though
Ryan Harris - 8 - Fine bowler
Peter Siddle - 4 - Bit off colour but still bowled OK in my eyes
Nathan Lyon - 7 - Incredible to think he was dropped for Agar less than two months ago.
RIP Philip Hughes - 1988-2014
The Wheel of Mediocrity | Compton, Root, Carberry, Robson, Trott, Lyth, Moeen, Hales | The wheel is forever
Founder and Grand Wizard of the CW Football Thread Statluminati. Potential hater of abilities. Blocked on twitter by Michael Vaughan, Brad McNamara and AtlCricket for my hard hitting truths.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)