Played a young Lachie Ferguson on a particularly bouncy astro deck when he would have been 18-19. His side were bowled out for 70 and he basically ran in and bowled short stuff for 7 overs. The massive gulf in ability between FC players and club ones was telling - Andy de Boorder handled him well, the rest were fleeing to square leg. Club players just aren't generally exposed to anything over 130, and when it does come they're not able to pick it up.
What explains is it is why someone like Roger Federer, who anyone would believe has lightning fast reflexes, goes into a sport like table tennis and can't for the life of him produce the reaction time to return serve...yet he can flick back a 250km John Isner rocket fairly comfortably. It's the subconscious cues that people can pick up in specific sports when they're exposed to them, but they don't cross over into different movements. Or, as in club cricket, they're just not accustomed timing-wise to something coming out of the hand at 130km +. The brain just doesn't recognise it. I know what some guys used to do before facing someone like Shoaib, Brett Lee etc was to turn the bowling machine up to 150 and feed it wide, so they were able to pick up the timing of hitting something at that pace. Still didn't substitute for the real thing, but it was the best way to train without access to bowlers of that speed.