Team Exchanges

[subshakerz]

Do these teams make these exchanges?

2000s Eng exchanging Vaughn for Mark Taylor?

70s Australia exchanging G Chappell for Keith Miller?

2010s SA exchanging Philander for Anderson?

Current India exchanging Bumrah for Kallis?

Current England exchanging Root for Botham?

90s SL exchanging Ranatunga for Stephen Fleming?

 

[Thala_0710]

Not sure
No
No
No
Hell no
No

 

[Migara]

all are nos.

While Fleming was an astute captain, he lacked that primal alpha male charachteristics of Ranatunga, which was a useful trait against incessant bullying SL received. He would have copped multiple bans, if played today due to his antics, but for the era, it was perfect.

 

[Coronis]

I think you’d exchange Vaughan for Taylor for sure. Better batsman, better captain, better fieldsman.

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Do these teams make these exchanges?

2000s Eng exchanging Vaughn for Mark Taylor?
Not sure.

70s Australia exchanging G Chappell for Keith Miller?
No. Australia had plenty of quicks but needed batting.

2010s SA exchanging Philander for Anderson?
No. Only if touring England.

Current India exchanging Bumrah for Kallis?
In India, yes. Against NZ, yes. Otherwise no.

Current England exchanging Root for Botham?
Yes - better for Baz Ball.

90s SL exchanging Ranatunga for Stephen Fleming?
Definitely. Fleming averaged 105 in SL.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Vaughan for Taylor is a yes, everything else a no.

 

[subshakerz]

all are nos.

While Fleming was an astute captain, he lacked that primal alpha male charachteristics of Ranatunga, which was a useful trait against incessant bullying SL received. He would have copped multiple bans, if played today due to his antics, but for the era, it was perfect.

He was a better bat though.

 

[Johan]

No.

Probably not.

Yes, Anderson is objectively the better bowler.

No.

probably Not, Root is better.

No.

 

[subshakerz]

Yes, Anderson is objectively the better bowler.

Yeah I thought I was the only one who would make that trade. Anderson succeeds in place Philander will not.