Outside of Murali, Kumble and Ashwin, who is the next best SC spinner?

[subshakerz]

Pretty straightforward.

 

[Johan]

Chandra

 

[subshakerz]

Chandra

Lol makes sense he did help win against England.

 

[Johan]

Lol makes sense he did help win against England.

and Australia, and West Indies, and to a lesser extent New Zealand, all in their homes

 

[subshakerz]

and Australia, and West Indies, and to a lesser extent New Zealand, all in their homes

I know bro just joshin ya

 

[honestbharani]

Murali


Ashwin

Kumble

Jadeja


That is the real ranking.

 

[subshakerz]

Points for each:

Prasanna: very high peer rating

Gupte: Sobers rating and being the godfather of SC spin

Saqlain: Innovator with doosra and THAT India series

Qadir: highest rated spinner of the 80s

Qasim: underrated away performer

Bedi: Best in the 4th innings

Herath: Kept SL competitive after Murali in a batting era

Chandra: Brilliant away matchwinning performances

Jadeja: The best record at home

 

[capt_Luffy]

Chandra
Bedi

Jadeja
Herath
Saqlain
Gupte
Prasanna

Qasim

Qadir

 

[DrWolverine]

Chandra

He was better than both Kumble & Ashwin overseas

He was also a bigger match winner than both overseas

 

[Johan]

Qasim is underrated among Pakistani spinners

 

[Johan]

Chandra
Bedi

Jadeja
Herath
Saqlain
Gupte
Prasanna

Qasim

Qadir

Herath is garbage, no reason for him above Saqlain, he should be with Qadir

 

[subshakerz]

I voted Saqlain. I think it's close between him and Chandra/Prasanna.

Saqlain:
- First spinner to really trouble Sachin and conquering India
- Very highly rated in the 90s
- Innovating a delivery which became a stock weapon for spinners ever since
- Won games away and home despite tougher home wickets than the others
- Very minor bonus points for being an ATG LOI spinner

 

[subshakerz]

Qasim is underrated among Pakistani spinners

Quite and I am not sure why. I guess it's the wrist spinner fixation.

 

[subshakerz]

Health is garbage, no reason for him above Saqlain, he should be with Qadir

Don't think Herath is that bad to be honest. Some very good yeoman performances.

 

[sledger]

Chawla

 

[vidiq]

Health is garbage, no reason for him above Saqlain, he should be with Qadir

Who is health ?

 

[SillyCowCorner1]

Ramesh Powar

 

[sayon basak]

Chandra/Bedi

 

[Gob]

Herath is way bigger than Saqlain

 

[Coronis]

lol @ Herath votes.

Averages 38 away and 37 outside Asia