marc71178
Eyes not spreadsheets
Having looked at their careers in comparison I find something amazing - Tufnell played only 3 games in Asia out of a career of 42 Tests!Tom Halsey said:Lol.
I think Tufnell had more natural ability, and could have been a great, but Giles has more discipline and fair play to him, he's taken advantage of that, and he deserves it.
Giles has 13 out of 38...
It'd be interesting to see who would be picked if both were in their prime at the same time - but I would guess Giles would get the nod due to his superior batting, fielding and attitude...