All-Time World XIs: Discussion Thread

[Red_Ink_Squid]

Look, McGrath and Imran tied. There was no winner there.

Eliminate them both; Woakes in.

Viv and Smith tied; both eliminated.

Woakes in twice.

 

[Johan]

Ftr, I absolutely am enjoying this and not really sure who I have in my AT team between Viv and Smith

let's go on to team A bruh

 

[capt_Luffy]

Yeah, It was decent. Thank you very much.

Booo

 

[subshakerz]

Ftr, I absolutely am enjoying this and not really sure who I have in my AT team between Viv and Smith

It's obviously Viv. Best argument is that you cannot put Smith until his career is over and then we can definitely not put Smith.

 

[capt_Luffy]

let's go on to team A bruh

Still like 18 hours left, and Smith and Viv are separated by a single vote.

 

[sayon basak]

Booo

Fk u.

 

[Johan]

I reckon if Viv doesn't make team 1, He shouldn't make it at all.

 

[capt_Luffy]

I reckon if Viv doesn't make team 1, I won't want him to make it at all.

Sounds familiar @sayon basak ?? And dude please, Viv's Great and all, but it's not like we are leaving Bradman or Sobers or Sachin. Think of Thala once, Lara got 2 votes and the other person's 2nd vote was Root!

 

[Johan]

Sounds familiar @sayon basak ?? And dude please, Viv's Great and all, but it's not like we are leaving Bradman or Sobers or Sachin. Think of Thala once, Lara got 2 votes and the other person's 2nd vote was Root!

Putting Sachin along Sobers and Bradman is an insult of the highest order to the two.

 

[subshakerz]

I reckon if Viv doesn't make team 1, I won't want him to make it at all.

Yeah it's an insult.

You know what would be an interesting exercise?

Making two of the most possibly equally matched ATG XIs (sans Bradman obviously). Any advantage has to be counterweighted with an advantage of the other team.

 

[Johan]

But Yeah, I'm just talking for myself, if It's not team 1 then I don't think I'll be voting for Viv in any subsequent round, would feel very insulting. Smith over him is somewhat alright though, I don't mind that.

 

[subshakerz]

Sounds familiar @sayon basak ?? And dude please, Viv's Great and all, but it's not like we are leaving Bradman or Sobers or Sachin.

It kinda is.

 

[capt_Luffy]

You guys are being such drama queens..... And it's when Viv's actually winning!!

 

[kyear2]

What sucks more is no reverser in the attack.

Just three new ball specialists.

At least have Wasim or Steyn.

CW posters honestly are such stat addicts.

I actually agree with you..

Wasim is just a better choice than Hadlee.

I saw a Red post from years ago, which bowler are you mist confident with tossing the old ball too 60 overs in on a dry pitch.

Plus need that variety in there.

Serious question, you're the Imran expert. Why didn't he bowl outswingers more?

 

[Johan]

You guys are being such drama queens..... And it's when Viv's actually winning!!

There's no drama, Sayon has a similar belief regarding Grace, it's a completely valid viewpoint to have.

 

[subshakerz]

Putting Sachin along Sobers and Bradman is an insult of the highest order to the two.

Viv is a more regular feature in ATG XIs than Sachin.

 

[capt_Luffy]

There's no drama, Sayon has a similar belief regarding Grace, it's a completely valid viewpoint to have.

Want a Grace vs Viv??

 

[capt_Luffy]

Also @subshakerz , incase Viv misses it, it won't have been so had you voted yesterday btw

 

[Prince EWS]

I reckon if Viv doesn't make team 1, He shouldn't make it at all.

Oh you definitely make me want to change to Smith now..

 

[Johan]

Want a Grace vs Viv??

8/10 Strawman