Who's Done the Most Damage?

[Thala_0710]

Luffy had @shortpitched713 thinking saying Williamson is as good as Ponting is an acceptable statement, that's some ATG work.

For a guy who says Hayden over Tendulkar, getting him to say anything feels possible

 

[Johan]

The reason I don't have any vote here is because I am the best at raising stocks here, not downgrading others.

 

[subshakerz]

Is Coronis responsible for Viv getting rated so low? If so, I have to give him his due.

 

[sayon basak]

For a guy who says Hayden over Tendulkar, getting him to say anything feels possible

No, he is not stupid enough to say Greenidge>Weekes.

 

[subshakerz]

The reason I don't have any vote here is because I am the best at rising stocks here, not downgrading others.

Greenidge.

 

[Thala_0710]

Is Coronis responsible for Viv getting rated so low? If so, I have to give him his due.

I haven't seen Viv get rated too low though... He even made the first XI ahead of Lara.... And Lara was ahead of Viv here in the poll few years ago.... Subz > Coronis and it's not close

 

[Johan]

Is Coronis responsible for Viv getting rated so low? If so, I have to give him his due.

Yeah, he and PEWS are responsible, Coronis is definitely the easier target of the two.

 

[Thala_0710]

No, he is not stupid enough to say Greenidge>Weekes.

I prefer enlightened but whatever floats your boat

 

[Johan]

Greenidge.

that was @Thala_0710's fault, he decided to argue Greenidge is a better Batsman than Weekes and Compton and singlehandedly made me anti Greenidge though I've never had him over Gooch or Gower

 

[subshakerz]

I haven't seen Viv get rated too low though... He even made the first XI ahead of Lara.... And Lara was ahead of Viv here in the poll few years ago.... Subz > Coronis and it's not close

Yeah I can say it's hard to find a thread now on Lara where his pace weakness isn't mentioned.

 

[Thala_0710]

I'll add in Greenidge and KP for you

 

[subshakerz]

that was @Thala_0710's fault, he decided to argue Greenidge is a better Batsman than Weekes and Compton and singlehandedly made me anti Greenidge though I've never had him over Gooch or Gower

Barry.

 

[Thala_0710]

I'll add in Greenidge and KP for you

It's not editable anymore.... Damage is done

 

[Johan]

No, he is not stupid enough to say Greenidge>Weekes.

Ok cook, a man who has Greenidge above Compton can't make fun of Hayden above Tendulkar, the latter is a worse take but only marginally so.

 

[Thala_0710]

that was @Thala_0710's fault, he decided to argue Greenidge is a better Batsman than Weekes and Compton and singlehandedly made me anti Greenidge though I've never had him over Gooch or Gower

Gower over Greenidge is nasty work tbf... Still not subz level though

 

[Johan]

Barry.

Barry fans are a bunch of fat nosed hypocrites who want special treatment for Barry, not a new standard, they literally want people to treat one Cricketer differently than all others and I will die on that hill.

 

[Thala_0710]

Ok cook, a man who has Greenidge above Compton can't make fun of Hayden above Tendulkar, the latter is a worse take but only marginally so.

You're basically saying that Tendulkar is a marginally better bat than Compton.... It's getting laughable now

 

[subshakerz]

I don't know why you put Jadeja for me. Historically I don't spend a lot of time on him

 

[Coronis]

Subs is not convincing because he pushes too hard and more importantly he debates Cricketers everyone has a strong opinion on via watching them, Coronis naturally would've more influence because he debates against Cricketers people haven't really watched and don't have strong opinions on, it's always easier to draw on a blank canvas than it is to draw over and edit an already made painting.

Yeah nobody has strong opinions on Viv.

 

[Johan]

Gower over Greenidge is nasty work tbf... Still not subz level though

not only is it not statistically incorrect but it was also a take many, many had in their playing days.