Who's Done the Most Damage?

[Thala_0710]

Rank in order

 

[Randomfan]

What do you mean by damage done? Do you mean actually changing opinion of lots of posters when it comes to stature? Or just having long arguements whenever these players are getting compared?

I have not been in forum for long enough to really participate in this poll but I would have rated Ambrose among top 5 pacers before joining the forum and I see that's what forum consensus is regarding Ambrose. I would have rated IK among the top 3 all rounders and top 8-10 bowlers and forum consensus is similar.

 

[Thala_0710]

What do you mean by damage done? Do you mean actually changing opinion of lots of posters when it comes to stature? Or just having long arguements whenever these players are getting compared?

Take both into account, but ofc the first one matters more

 

[Johan]

You? With Weekes? Brother you didn't do ****

 

[Thala_0710]

You? With Weekes? Brother you didn't do ****

I haven't even begun yet

 

[Thala_0710]

Anyway, rank in order and vote for the top choice

 

[Johan]

I haven't even begun yet

I have already found a way to salvage the 1957 England tour, Weekes is safe for now.

 

[Coronis]

Take both into account, but ofc the first one matters more

I mean. The second one would obviously lead to a unanimous vote

 

[Thala_0710]

I mean. The second one would obviously lead to a unanimous vote

Yeah

 

[Johan]

As far as Long posts go, I have no doubt I can outwrite either Subs or Kyear while not even taking it seriously but the way Subs and Kyear have argued about the same character accross several threads for several years and rehashed the same conversation five million times, that's beyond my reach and it's truly inspiring.

 

[Thala_0710]

As far as Long posts go, I have no doubt I can outwrite either Subs or Kyear while not even taking it seriously but the way Subs and Kyear have argued about the same character accross several threads for several years and rehashed the same conversation five million times, that's beyond my reach and it's truly inspiring.

Yet you voted for Coronis

 

[Johan]

Yet you voted for Coronis

Subs is not convincing because he pushes too hard and more importantly he debates Cricketers everyone has a strong opinion on via watching them, Coronis naturally would've more influence because he debates against Cricketers people haven't really watched and don't have strong opinions on, it's always easier to draw on a blank canvas than it is to draw over and edit an already made painting.

 

[Johan]

Thala has also done great damage to Gordon Greenidge.

 

[Thala_0710]

You can't vote for yourself. Don't be so proud @capt_Luffy

 

[capt_Luffy]

You can't vote for yourself. Don't be so proud @capt_Luffy

I am just built different. And like, I don't really think I downgrade Harbhajan much. I mean, how much lower can he even go??

 

[Thala_0710]

I mean, how much lower can be even go??

Proves the point frankly

 

[Johan]

Luffy had @shortpitched713 thinking saying Williamson is as good as Ponting is an acceptable statement, that's some ATG work.

 

[Thala_0710]

And change your vote

 

[capt_Luffy]

Luffy had @shortpitched713 thinking saying Williamson is as good as Ponting is an acceptable statement, that's some ATG work.

He also thinks Hayden is as good as Tendulkar is an acceptable statement, but I will take it

 

[subshakerz]

Voted for Imran vs Kyear2, because it's iconic. Subz is close, but others are just NPCs. If one day kyear2 decided to end all the Imran bashing, you guys will miss it.

I don't think he has been that effective in downgrading Imran though. Maybe I could be wrong though Hadlees stock has risen here compared to Imran in recent years.