Warne/McGrath vs Hadlee/Kallis

[Johan]

Bro you can try, but Greenidge>Weekes now is your 2nd Worst take, unless you really think they are faaaar away.

What's the worst take?

 

[capt_Luffy]

What's the worst take?

Van Dijk being much ahead of Moore.

 

[Johan]

Van Dijk being much ahead of Moore.

Unironically? Then the take rank in this order

Worst Take
Van Dijk a league ahead of Moore

Second Worst Take
Greenidge ahead of Compton

Third Worst Take
Greenidge ahead of Weekes

Fourth Worst Take
Kanhai ahead of Compton

Fifth Worse Take
Kanhai ahead of Weekes

 

[Thala_0710]

Van Dijk being much ahead of Moore.

He's not much ahead, but he is ahead for sure

 

[capt_Luffy]

Unironically? Then the take rank in this order

Worst Take
Van Dijk a league ahead of Moore

Second Worst Take
Greenidge ahead of Compton

Third Worst Take
Greenidge ahead of Weekes

Fourth Worst Take
Kanhai ahead of Compton

Fifth Worse Take
Kanhai ahead of Weekes

Combine 2nd and 3rd and 4th and 5th into one imo

 

[Coronis]

Like which game? McWarne are certainly better than Seales and Shamar no contest but as much as I rate bowlers over batsmen, you still do need runs to work with. And McWarne would also have to deal with WI catching/fielding. They may restrict Australia to a lower score but trust me, somehow WI would find a way to score less. Much less.

Either of the first two. Especially game 1, you think current Australia would have scored 310 in the second innings against McWarne? That Head, Webster and Carey are all scoring 60s? 150 far more likely and then Windies would’ve won. And all that is assuming they still manage 180 in the first.