Top 50 Greatest test batters

[capt_Luffy]

De Villiers is definitely not top 30.

With everything to criticize from Compton missing the cut all together to Greenidge and Kohli in Top 30..... You select ABD!!!?

 

[sayon basak]

lol I like Kimber but his book isn't confirmation of anything for real, and Gavaskar over Sobers is a dead giveaway of India catering.

Maybe he still believes that Gavaskar averaged 100 against spinners?

 

[Thala_0710]

lol I like Kimber but his book isn't confirmation of anything for real, and Gavaskar over Sobers is a dead giveaway of India catering.

Almost everywhere there's a push for the openers and a bit of downgrade for the guys batting at 5, so heavily disagree

 

[sayon basak]

With everything to criticize from Compton missing the cut all together to Greenidge and Kohli in Top 30..... You select ABD!!!?

He knew others already mentioned it. So, he did the task left for him.

 

[OverratedSanity]

lol I like Kimber but his book isn't confirmation of anything for real, and Gavaskar over Sobers is a dead giveaway of India catering.

He's overrated openers across the board imo.

 

[Johan]

Almost everywhere there's a push for the openers and a bit of downgrade for the guys batting at 5, so heavily disagree

But then why is Kohli above Boycott if Jarrod values longevity and opening, especially since opening in England or New Zealand is the hardest thing.

 

[Thala_0710]

But then why is Kohli above Boycott if Jarrod values longevity and opening, especially since opening in England or New Zealand is the hardest thing.

Because of the selfish thing and the peak thing

 

[subshakerz]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

 

[Johan]

With everything to criticize from Compton missing the cut all together to Greenidge and Kohli in Top 30..... You select ABD!!!?

Compton below Boycott is a take of all time.

 

[Thala_0710]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

Chanderpaul over Waugh yes
Dravid over ponting isn't a howler I'd say

 

[Johan]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

It's Virender Sehwag over Graeme Pollock for me.

 

[subshakerz]

He overrated Sachin in most of his videos only to get more views
It's still Highly debatable
, Hobbs is unarguably the best after bradman.

Come on, I will say Kimber isn't playing to the gallery. He seems honest in his presentation. And I don't think he would have any issue putting Hobbs no.2 if he felt it.

 

[sayon basak]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

Dravid over Ponting is not even bad when you look at some of the other rankings.

 

[Johan]

Maybe he still believes that Gavaskar averaged 100 against spinners?

That's cooked.

 

[OverratedSanity]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

Dravid over ponting is justifiable even if I disagree.

The Chanderpaul one is terrible.

 

[capt_Luffy]

The real howlers:

Dravid over Ponting

Chanderpaul over Steve Waugh lol

When Cook is Everton Weekes, calling Dravid over Ponting a howler is stupid.

 

[sayon basak]

When Cook is Everton Weekes, calling Dravid over Ponting a howler is stupid.

That'd be something.

 

[Thala_0710]

When Cook is Everton Weekes, calling Dravid over Ponting a howler is stupid.

Might not go to the extent of Cook but I do believe Weekes is quite overrated here

 

[Johan]

With everything to criticize from Compton missing the cut all together to Greenidge and Kohli in Top 30..... You select ABD!!!?

Compton should be wherever he placed Barrington imo, one slot below or one slot above.

 

[sayon basak]

Might not go to the extent of Cook but I do believe Weekes is quite overrated here

@Johan get started.