• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Ricky Ponting vs Kumar Sangakkara

Better Cricketer

  • Total voters
    31
Coronis

Coronis

Hall of Fame Member
Well I rate Sanga slightly higher as a bat, so theres that. Curious, where did Sanga usually field after he stopped keeping?
 
Johan

Johan

Hall of Fame Member
I'm gonna vote on batting, I think Ponting is a slightly better Batsman.

I generally have Ponting as the best of the four between Ponting, Kallis, Dravid and Sangakkara, I know some like to break away Ponting and Kallis from Sangakkara and Dravid but just feels like white supremacy to me, All four are very close and just about any order is valid, I just think I liked watching Ponting the most and he was a little more skilled.
 
kyear2

kyear2

Hall of Fame Member
sayon basak said:
PFK tier take imo.
Click to expand...
Again, you're entitled to your opinion.

To be clear, not particularly close for me means I can clearly separate them. Which I can.

Johan said:
alright that's just a horrendous take, Sangakkara was amazing.
Click to expand...
There's an old saying, you may not remember what they said, but you always remember how they made you feel. Punter scared me, no other batsman ever has.

I am not particularly great at remembering the dates and specific innings, I do very clearly recall Punter being seen as part of the big three.
At that point he was seen as more consistent than Lara and more destructive than Sachin.
He was at the helm of, and THE man for arguably the strongest line up in modest history.

He was discussed in the best after Bradman conversation, and as much as that's discredited today, that's hindsight and not the feeling in real time. Sangakarra was never seen in that light.

There was a more than good chance that he was going to finish his career with an average around 60, while playing the way he did. Genuinely believed at one point he was going to rated higher than Lara. And while I didn't think he was better, the numbers were there.

Johan said:
I'm gonna vote on batting, I think Ponting is a slightly better Batsman.

I generally have Ponting as the best of the four between Ponting, Kallis, Dravid and Sangakkara, I know some like to break away Ponting and Kallis from Sangakkara and Dravid but just feels like white supremacy to me, All four are very close and just about any order is valid, I just think I liked watching Ponting the most and he was a little more skilled.
Click to expand...
I'm never going to me a member of the charter of the white supremacists movement, so can't comment in that.
Punter was a modern day Viv, no the bowling wasn't quite the same, but his dismissal of it surely was. I prefer aggressive batsman who can add impetus to an innings and tern the game in a session as required. He was for me at the time, and now, the best of the fraudulent four.
Kallis was dour, perceived as selfish and existed in his own cocoon at times... He also played on by some distance the toughest home pitches.
Dravid was next, and while he escaped the charges levied against Kallis, he was very similar. While Kallis was called selfish, Dravid was the anchor, or more accurately, the Wall. He was clutch though and I have him right behind Kallis.
Sanga was not only last, but easily so. The numbers are there, the when, where, on what and against who, just isn't, at least not for me.
He was the quietest of the era, and that can't be attributed to playing for SL because Murali was very much in the spot light.

So for me Punter isn't tiers ahead, but he's clearly so.
 
Migara

Migara

International Coach
Sanga and it's not even remotely close. Ponting don't have a secondary skill anywhere close to the quality of Sanga's keeping.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top