Peter May vs Denis Compton vs Geoffrey Boycott

[Johan]

rank them

 

[Johan]

been a while since I posted these, Boycott by far having the best video even though he's the worst bat

 

[sayon basak]

been a while since I posted these, Boycott by far having the best video even though he's the worst bat

Didn't you once think that Gavaskar and Boycott were close?

 

[Johan]

Didn't you once think that Gavaskar and Boycott were close?

still do

 

[sayon basak]

still do

And yet he's worse than Compton or May? How close are Gavaskar and Boycott actually in your ranking?

 

[subshakerz]

Tough

 

[Johan]

And yet he's worse than Compton or May? How close are Gavaskar and Boycott actually in your ranking?

I posted my top 50, IIRC Boycott was around 30 and Gavaskar around 10

 

[sayon basak]

I posted my top 50, IIRC Boycott was around 30 and Gavaskar around 10

Are Hutton and Barrington close? Excuse any impudence, I'm just trying to get what close means.

 

[Johan]

Are Hutton and Barrington close? Excuse any impudence, I'm just trying to get what close means.

Don't worry, I'm very confused myself on what I consider close and what I don't

 

[sayon basak]

Don't worry, I'm very confused myself on what I consider close and what I don't

Listen to me, you won't be confused anymore.

Start rating Boycott in your top 20.

 

[Johan]

Listen to me, you won't be confused anymore.

Start rating Boycott in your top 20.

I'll give Top 25 a thought

while we are at it, Fix your vote.

 

[sayon basak]

I'll give Top 25 a thought

while we are at it, Fix your vote.

Top 25 automatically means ahead of both Compton and May, so my vote isn't invalid.

 

[Johan]

Top 25 automatically means ahead of both Compton and May, so my vote isn't invalid.

Compton was 23 actually, 22 now.

 

[sayon basak]

Compton was 23 actually, 22 now.

Yeah, not top 25 for me iirc.

 

[Johan]

Yeah, not top 25 for me iirc.

Putting Boycott over the Ws would hurt my soul but maybe I'll do it.

 

[sayon basak]

Putting Boycott over the Ws would hurt my soul but maybe I'll do it.

It'll be wrong, but your decision is yours.

 

[Johan]

It'll be wrong, but your decision is yours.

I actually think Headley and Weekes is close and Weekes is like 26 or 27 and Headley 12, what a mess

 

[sayon basak]

I actually think Headley and Weekes is close and Weekes is like 26 or 27 and Headley 12, what a mess

TBH, You get to define what close is. I thought you'd reply saying that 10 and 30 are still close because top tier batters start to get close after top 5, more so when we start to go down the list.

 

[Johan]

TBH, You get to define what close is. I thought you'd reply saying that 10 and 30 are still close because top tier batters start to get close after top 5, more so when we start to go down the list.

that's true

 

[Coronis]

I could swap Compton and May