He can field and he's an unremarkable batsman. Totally agree with that.
However, there's plenty of players who should be ahead of him:
Flynn, Ryder, Taylor, Hay, Broom, Todd, Ingram, Spearman, Sinclair, Parlane, Parlane, Horne, Hiini, Stewart, Astle (T), Astle (N), Astle (J), Bruce Edgar, Geoff Howarth, H.T. Davis... Even Marshall (H).