• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Jasprit Bumrah vs Dennis Lillee

Who is the better test bowler?


  • Total voters
    23

Coronis

Hall of Fame Member
Only counting series they played in:

Marshall
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 3 tests (debut)
10 5 test series, 7x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests

McGrath
1 6 test series, 6 tests
8 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Hadlee
rip Hadlee

Steyn
1 5 test series, 3 tests (debut)

Ambrose
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests
10 5 test series, 8x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Imran
2 6 test series, 5 tests, 3 tests
4 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 1x 2 tests

Wasim
3 5 test series, 2x 5 tests, 4 tests

Lillee
3 6 test series, 2x 6 tests, 5 tests
4 5 test series, 5 tests, 2 tests (debut) 2x 1 test

Donald
5 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Trueman
15 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests, 2 tests, 4x 1 test

Garner
1 6 test series, 5 tests
7 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 test series, 2 test series

Lindwall
11 5 test series, 5x 5 test, 4x 4 tests, 2x 2 tests

Waqar
1 5 test series, 5 tests

Holding
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests (debut)
7 5 test series 2x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests

Davidson
9 5 test series 6x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Pollock
7 5 test series 5x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Walsh
2 6 test series 2x 6 tests
14 5 test series 11x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests, 1 test

Cummins
5 5 test series 4x 5 tests, 4 tests

Anderson
18 5 test series 9x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 4x 3 tests, 2x 1 test

Rabada
rip Rabada

Bumrah
4 5 test series* 2x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests

Another could be 4 or 3, depending how this current series goes.

Percentage of 5 test series playing all matches

Waqar 100%
Ambrose 80%
Cummins 80%
Walsh 78.57%
Imran 75%
Garner 71.43%
Pollock 71.43%
Marshall 70%
Davidson 66.67%
Wasim 66.67%
McGrath 62.5%
Donald 60%
Anderson 50%
Lindwall 45.45%
Bumrah 40%
Trueman 33.33%
Holding 28.57%
Lillee 25%
Steyn 0%

As expected, Waqar on top
 
Last edited:

Swamp Witch Hattie

U19 12th Man
Only counting series they played in:

Marshall
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 3 tests (debut)
10 5 test series, 7x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests

McGrath
1 6 test series, 6 tests
8 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Hadlee
rip Hadlee

Steyn
1 5 test series, 3 tests (debut)

Ambrose
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests
10 5 test series, 8x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Imran
2 6 test series, 5 tests, 3 tests
4 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 1x 2 tests

Wasim
3 5 test series, 2x 5 tests, 4 tests

Lillee
3 6 test series, 2x 6 tests, 5 tests
4 5 test series, 5 tests, 2 tests (debut) 2x 1 test

Donald
5 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Trueman
15 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests, 2 tests, 4x 1 test

Garner
1 6 test series, 5 tests
7 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 test series, 2 test series

Lindwall
11 5 test series, 5x 5 test, 4x 4 tests, 2x 2 tests

Waqar
1 5 test series, 5 tests

Holding
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests (debut)
7 5 test series 2x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests

Davidson
9 5 test series 6x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Pollock
7 5 test series 5x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Walsh
2 6 test series 2x 6 tests
14 5 test series 11x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests, 1 test

Cummins
5 5 test series 4x 5 tests, 4 tests

Anderson
18 5 test series 9x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 4x 3 tests, 2x 1 test

Rabada
rip Rabada

Bumrah
4 5 test series* 2x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests

Another could be 4 or 3, depending how this current series goes.

Percentage of 5 test series playing all matches

Waqar 100%
Ambrose 80%
Cummins 80%
Walsh 78.57%
Imran 75%
Garner 71.43%
Pollock 71.43%
Marshall 70%
Davidson 66.67%
Wasim 66.67%
McGrath 62.5%
Donald 60%
Steyn 60%
Anderson 50%
Lindwall 45.45%
Bumrah 40%
Trueman 33.33%
Holding 28.57%
Lillee 25%

As expected, Waqar on top
FFS, Coronis. You gave me a fright. I found your post in truncated form as part of Search results and thought for a second that Hadlee had died.

Tremendous work, BTW!
 

capt_Luffy

Hall of Fame Member
Only counting series they played in:

Marshall
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 3 tests (debut)
10 5 test series, 7x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests

McGrath
1 6 test series, 6 tests
8 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Hadlee
rip Hadlee

Steyn
1 5 test series, 3 tests (debut)

Ambrose
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests
10 5 test series, 8x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Imran
2 6 test series, 5 tests, 3 tests
4 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 1x 2 tests

Wasim
3 5 test series, 2x 5 tests, 4 tests

Lillee
3 6 test series, 2x 6 tests, 5 tests
4 5 test series, 5 tests, 2 tests (debut) 2x 1 test

Donald
5 5 test series, 3x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Trueman
15 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests, 2 tests, 4x 1 test

Garner
1 6 test series, 5 tests
7 5 test series, 5x 5 tests, 4 test series, 2 test series

Lindwall
11 5 test series, 5x 5 test, 4x 4 tests, 2x 2 tests

Waqar
1 5 test series, 5 tests

Holding
2 6 test series, 6 tests, 5 tests (debut)
7 5 test series 2x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 2x 3 tests

Davidson
9 5 test series 6x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests, 2 tests

Pollock
7 5 test series 5x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests

Walsh
2 6 test series 2x 6 tests
14 5 test series 11x 5 tests, 2x 4 tests, 1 test

Cummins
5 5 test series 4x 5 tests, 4 tests

Anderson
18 5 test series 9x 5 tests, 3x 4 tests, 4x 3 tests, 2x 1 test

Rabada
rip Rabada

Bumrah
4 5 test series* 2x 5 tests, 4 tests, 3 tests

Another could be 4 or 3, depending how this current series goes.

Percentage of 5 test series playing all matches

Waqar 100%
Ambrose 80%
Cummins 80%
Walsh 78.57%
Imran 75%
Garner 71.43%
Pollock 71.43%
Marshall 70%
Davidson 66.67%
Wasim 66.67%
McGrath 62.5%
Donald 60%
Steyn 60%
Anderson 50%
Lindwall 45.45%
Bumrah 40%
Trueman 33.33%
Holding 28.57%
Lillee 25%

As expected, Waqar on top
How is Steyn 60%?? If I get it right, it's not how many Tests they played in the available 5 Test Serieses (would make Bumrah 85%), but how many Series they played whole. Should make Steyn at 0%
 

Coronis

Hall of Fame Member
How is Steyn 60%?? If I get it right, it's not how many Tests they played in the available 5 Test Serieses (would make Bumrah 85%), but how many Series they played whole. Should make Steyn at 0%
Yeah Steyn’s is a mistake. Cos I did originally start writing it out the other way, before realising that wasn’t the question asked. Or maybe I just did 3/5. Can’t remember
 

Swamp Witch Hattie

U19 12th Man
Walsh was an iron man, beginning to end, and bowling a **** tom of overs.
I discovered this a few months ago, something you probably already know, and was shocked: Walsh was superhuman over the last 11 1/2 months of his Test career. He played EIGHTEEN Test matches, took 84 wickets (WPM = 4.67) at an average of 20.25 while bowling a massive 151 BPI:

Walsh's last year in Test cricket.JPG
 

Top