• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Extra Team Trades

R

reyrey

First Class Debutant
2010s England exchange Broad for Richie Benaud?

Yes. Benaud would be doing Moeen's role in the team, but better. Plus a decent captain which England desperately needed

90s SA exchange S Pollock for G Pollock?

No, but it's a coin toss. 90s S Pollock was a beast

2000s Aus exchange Gilly for Keith Miller?

Yes. I'd want Miller for his bowling as Australia never really had 4 bowlers all firing at the same time. Miller as a number 8 kinda makes up for Gilly missing and also gives the option of goin the 3 seamer, 2 spinner route when needed.

2000s Pakistan exchange Younis Khan for Kapil Dev?

Yes. Pak lacked paced bowling depth and Misbah who missed most of the 2000s can take Khans spot

2010s India exchange Jadeja for Graeme Swann?

No. Mainly cos what's the point with Ashwin around. If Ashwin wasn't a part of the equation then yes.
 
Sliferxxxx

Sliferxxxx

State Vice-Captain
subshakerz said:
Do team makes these trades?

2010s England exchange Broad for Richie Benaud?

90s SA exchange S Pollock for G Pollock?

2000s Aus exchange Gilly for Keith Miller?

2000s Pakistan exchange Younis Khan for Kapil Dev?

2010s India exchange Jadeja for Graeme Swann?
Click to expand...
Yes
No
Tough one likely no
No
NO!!!
 
Coronis

Coronis

Hall of Fame Member
Yes
Maybe. Seems like a no brainer at first, but SA really didn’t have bowling stocks outside Donald and Pollock til the 00’s. Idk though, perhaps Donald could have taken on a more Murali/Hadlee role and Pollock being there would be a great help. Don’t know if he had the body to withstand those high loads at his pace though.
Very tough. Could go either way on this. I think they would, especially if say its before they really knew the impact of Gilchrist. Would be fun in that situation if say, South Africa or England were to be able to have him.
No (unless they know what’s gonna happen to all their pace bowlers in advance)
No - This discourse about Swann vs Jadeja outside of Asia…. who says Swanna would even be getting picked and getting those opportunities tbh.
 
subshakerz

subshakerz

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
reyrey said:
2010s England exchange Broad for Richie Benaud?

Yes. Benaud would be doing Moeen's role in the team, but better. Plus a decent captain which England desperately needed

90s SA exchange S Pollock for G Pollock?

No, but it's a coin toss. 90s S Pollock was a beast

2000s Aus exchange Gilly for Keith Miller?

Yes. I'd want Miller for his bowling as Australia never really had 4 bowlers all firing at the same time. Miller as a number 8 kinda makes up for Gilly missing and also gives the option of goin the 3 seamer, 2 spinner route when needed.

2000s Pakistan exchange Younis Khan for Kapil Dev?

Yes. Pak lacked paced bowling depth and Misbah who missed most of the 2000s can take Khans spot

2010s India exchange Jadeja for Graeme Swann?

No. Mainly cos what's the point with Ashwin around. If Ashwin wasn't a part of the equation then yes.
Click to expand...
Good responses.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top