Does Shai Hope get into an All-Time ODI XI for West Indies ?

[Isura]

Shai fing Hope coming in before Viv seems cringe

 

[reyrey]

Open with Shai Hope or have him as a floater around number 4 if wickets fall early and have him play the anchor/strike rotation role for all big hitters.

 

[Sliferxxxx]

Open with Shai Hope or have him as a floater around number 4 if wickets fall early and have him play the anchor/strike rotation role for all big hitters.

I wouldn't open with him. Because you're already leaving out one of Haynes, Gayle or Greenidge. Opening with Hope means two get left out. Id go with this team still:

Gayle
Haynes
Viv*
Lara
Hope+
Sarwan
Hooper
Holding
Roberts
Garner
Ambrose

 

[SillyCowCorner1]

I wouldn't open with him. Because you're already leaving out one of Haynes, Gayle or Greenidge. Opening with Hope means two get left out. Id go with this team still:

Gayle
Haynes
Viv*
Lara
Hope+
Sarwan
Hooper
Holding
Roberts
Garner
Ambrose

My wildcard is Shiv opening

 

[reyrey]

I wouldn't open with him. Because you're already leaving out one of Haynes, Gayle or Greenidge. Opening with Hope means two get left out. Id go with this team still:

Gayle
Haynes
Viv*
Lara
Hope+
Sarwan
Hooper
Holding
Roberts
Garner
Ambrose

Leaving out Lloyd and including Sarwan is a bold call.

Haynes and Greenidge were great in their era, but Shai can play that anchor role and you can then pick more match winners in the middle order of which there are plenty to choose from.

 

[capt_Luffy]

I wouldn't open with him. Because you're already leaving out one of Haynes, Gayle or Greenidge. Opening with Hope means two get left out. Id go with this team still:

Gayle
Haynes
Viv*
Lara
Hope+
Sarwan
Hooper
Holding
Roberts
Garner
Ambrose

Think Lloyd should be there.