• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Cricket Counterfactuals

Ali TT

International Captain
If Sobers hadn't survived the car crash that killed Collie Smith in 1959, what might that have meant for the development of West Indies cricket?
 

Yeoman

State 12th Man
A couple of English domestic decisions with wide ranging consequences:

1.What if the Gillette Cup, the first limited overs competition, had not been introduced in 1963?
2. What if someone on the ECB could do basic maths and realised that the 7 votes out of 19 against the introduction of the T20 cup in 2002 meant that it did not have 2/3 approval and therefore should not have replaced the B&H Cup?

Now one could argue that someone else, perhaps outside of the official structures, such as a Packer-style figure or an ICL type league would have come up with the ideas for limited over cricket and T20 anyway. But perhaps they would not.
 

LangleyburyCCPlayer

International Debutant
Wales were tied in points with Sri Lanka in the 1979 ICC Trophy, if Wales win that group and go on to qualify for that year’s World Cup, do Sri Lanka get Test status a few years later? Do Wales go it alone and play Tests?
 

Yeoman

State 12th Man
Wales were tied in points with Sri Lanka in the 1979 ICC Trophy, if Wales win that group and go on to qualify for that year’s World Cup, do Sri Lanka get Test status a few years later? Do Wales go it alone and play Tests?
Sri Lanka had been knocking on the door for a few years so I imagine they would have got test status in any event, even if delayed by a couple of years.

As I see it, Glamorgan being a first class county, has always been the poisoned chalice for Wales as an independent cricketing entity. Its reliance on ECB funding creates a strong vested interest against separation. This would not change if Wales made it to the World Cup.
 

ma1978

International Regular
Javed Miandad miraculously gets Pakistan past India in the 1996 World Cup and Pakistan goes on to beat Australia in the finals
 

LangleyburyCCPlayer

International Debutant
Sri Lanka had been knocking on the door for a few years so I imagine they would have got test status in any event, even if delayed by a couple of years.

As I see it, Glamorgan being a first class county, has always been the poisoned chalice for Wales as an independent cricketing entity. Its reliance on ECB funding creates a strong vested interest against separation. This would not change if Wales made it to the World Cup.
I know cricket is not the most popular sport in Wales, but it always struck me as weird that they don’t have their own team, Scotland were in a similar position I believe up until the 90s(?), but they broke away, though obviously without any representation at FC level. There is precedent for Welsh teams to play in England while having their own team, it’s what happens in football, but that was what it was like from the very start
 

Top