Bill Woodfull vs Graeme Smith

[Coronis]

In term of usefulness to the team

1. Malcolm Marshall
2. Glenn McGrath
3. Richard Hadlee
4. Sydney Barnes
5. Curtly Ambrose
6. Dale Steyn
7. Imran Khan
8. Shane Warne
9. Muttiah Muralitharan
10. Bill O Reilly
11. Fred Trueman
12. Dennis Lillee
13. Wasim Akram
14. Joel Garner
15. Allan Donald
16. Ray Lindwall
17. Michael Holding
18. Jasprit Bumrah (right now)
19. Shaun Pollock
20. James Anderson/Courtney Walsh

not in my top 20 yet, No sir.

cbf doing for rest but since we’re doing “usefulness for team”.. win percentage with and without the player during their careers

Marshall 53.09 vs 32.00
McGrath 67.74 vs 54.55
Hadlee 25.58 vs 0.00
Barnes 48.15 vs 35.48
Bumrah 44.44 vs 69.23

India is better without Bumrah.

 

[OverratedSanity]

cbf doing for rest but since we’re doing “usefulness for team”.. win percentage with and without the player during their careers

Marshall 53.09 vs 32.00
McGrath 67.74 vs 54.55
Hadlee 25.58 vs 0.00
Barnes 48.15 vs 35.48
Bumrah 44.44 vs 69.23

India is better without Bumrah.

I mean this is just because the vast majority of the tests he's missed have been in India IIRC.

Hadlee though WAG

 

[Cricket Bliss]

But one thing i am sure.. he once posted a link somewhere in which a pundit claims that Kallis is not an all rounder and is just a batsmen who knows to bowl…comparing him with Shane Warne who averages just 17 with the bat!! and subs was supporting that claim suggesting that Kallis was never a true all rounder..but a batsman who knows to bowl and he is top among that category

tried to find it…but couldn’t since subs mentioning Kallis is infinite here

@sayon basak