LangleyburyCCPlayer
International Debutant
I don’t think Darren Pattinson ever thought he’d play for England!
-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
No hopers who made it
- Thread starter Bahnz
- Start date
LangleyburyCCPlayer
International Debutant
Wasn’t he a spinner when he was playing in South Africa, or was he as much of a spinner as Steve Smith was?
Coronis
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Clearly need your first post on each of the Fab Four
He played against England in a tour match in 99/00 as a spinner batting down there order. Think he was only 19 though at the time.
I think "New Zealand cricket" would be a good answer to this thread. Have long exceeded expectations and so many of their players been greater than their apparent records might suggest.
He always rated Ringo
trundler
Request Your Custom Title Now!
Prodigies don't count. Players who merely exceeded expectations aren't quite no-hopers either. Only Henry, Harris, Wagner and Ishant have been valid examples so far. You have to improve by like 50% or more compared to the first half of your career to qualify for this thread imo.
Wasn't Ishant highly regarded as a youngster though?
I think Collingwood is a good shout - he was essentially injury cover who filled in a couple of holes in the England side at the start of his test career but then became undroppable as a middle order stalwart. His f/c average was something like 33 and he was perceived as a limited over specialist.
trundler
Request Your Custom Title Now!
Yeah I'll allow Collingwood and Mitchell too.
I'm not too familiar about Ben Duckett's FC career before Bazball but he was supposedly a middling middle order batter for ages, was he not?
thierry henry
International Coach
Feel like Wagner is being a bit misrepresented here. He fits the thread in the sense of having a mediocre start to his test career, but he certainly didn't come out of nowhere to play test cricket. He was a highly-rated youngster in South Africa and was only 21 when he last played there so his struggles to crack top tier FC cricket I feel are a little exaggerated. Sure, maybe he would've continued to have a frustrating time over there but then isn't that a story we've heard a million times about obviously talented players? He immediately walked into FC cricket in NZ and there was quite a lot of hype around him during his qualification period.
The reason he was initially a bit of a disappointment at test level was because there was that hype around him in NZ. The perception of him as this gritty underdog making the most of limited talents is more about the unorthodox version of Wagner that emerged during the course of his test career - that came out of left field, but the man himself didn't.
The reason he was initially a bit of a disappointment at test level was because there was that hype around him in NZ. The perception of him as this gritty underdog making the most of limited talents is more about the unorthodox version of Wagner that emerged during the course of his test career - that came out of left field, but the man himself didn't.
Starfighter
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Not gonna try make a specific threshold, but people keep naming players who just took a few years to establish themselves at test level. I mean Sobers, who arguably debuted a couple of years too early? Whereas Harris spent the first five years of his career being not even first class standard.
Athlai
Not Terrible
Ishant was a prodigy because Indias bowling sucked.
He did also bowl decently on some hard road tours too.
Prince EWS
Global Moderator
Mark Richardson
Immenso
International Vice-Captain
Maybe Mitch Santner as a test player.
Although an almost decade long all-format player having a golden period, in his weakest format, is not off the scale. You could say he's had enough 'in-match practice' I guess.
Personally. I was always comfortable with Santner's role in that very settled and experienced NZ test team around the turn of the decade. While acknowledging that he and the second opener were the weakest links, but he had a role and he added balanced that enabled NZ to puruse their wagnerball tactics. E.g. they wouldn't have selected CdG without Santner, and you would have had Wagner bowling at different 'ball-agedness times' without CdG.
But now, maybe he is actually good in his own rights?
Although an almost decade long all-format player having a golden period, in his weakest format, is not off the scale. You could say he's had enough 'in-match practice' I guess.
Personally. I was always comfortable with Santner's role in that very settled and experienced NZ test team around the turn of the decade. While acknowledging that he and the second opener were the weakest links, but he had a role and he added balanced that enabled NZ to puruse their wagnerball tactics. E.g. they wouldn't have selected CdG without Santner, and you would have had Wagner bowling at different 'ball-agedness times' without CdG.
But now, maybe he is actually good in his own rights?
Immenso
International Vice-Captain
I think a few of the recent test bowlers (of the last decade) as contenders. Are guys who benefited from concentrating on wobble ball rather than swing, as it became more widespread. E.g. Henry, and (I'm guessing) Lakmal?
I think Ishant Sharma benfited from technology and analysts. E.g. becoming a LHB specialist and bowling around the wicket to them (with his natural swing) with the knowledge that DRS and ball-tracking had turned a century's worth of assumed knowledge to kak.
I think Ishant Sharma benfited from technology and analysts. E.g. becoming a LHB specialist and bowling around the wicket to them (with his natural swing) with the knowledge that DRS and ball-tracking had turned a century's worth of assumed knowledge to kak.
Prince EWS
Global Moderator
I've been thinking players who started their domestic careers in one role and it didn't work out so they reinvented themselves and ended up Test standard in their new roles could be good examples.
So Mark Richardson, Colin Miller, Scott Styris, Nathan Astle, Thilan Samaraweera. Brad Hogg, Johan Botha and Colin Munro if applied to white ball cricket.
(and no, Steve Smith does not count, he was always a batting prodigy despite the mythology)
Last edited: