All-Time World XIs: Discussion Thread

[Johan]

Boycott and Barry then for 4th.

Nah I'd probably go like

Hobbs
Hutton

Gavaskar
Grace

Sutcliffe
Boycott

Trumper
Richards

Trumper and Barry sounds cool, Your guy and Kyear's guy, maybe a PC thread idea...

 

[capt_Luffy]

Tho if Grace and Sunny win, I'd get Boycott and Sutcliffe in third XI and Trumper will open with Gooch

Sutcliffe and Barry for the third, Boycott and Trumper for the 4th

Such a tragedy Trumper missed out on the Aussie XI

 

[Johan]

Sutcliffe and Barry for the third, Boycott and Trumper for the 4th

Barry over Boycott is the equivalent of picking Van Der Bijl over Rabada, Les Jackson over Statham or Rajinder Goel over Anil Kumble.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Nah I'd probably go like

Hobbs
Hutton

Gavaskar
Grace

Sutcliffe
Boycott

Trumper
Richards

Trumper and Barry sounds cool, Your guy and Kyear's guy, maybe a PC thread idea...

Victor is the himest player Ever

 

[Thala_0710]

Such a tragedy Trumper missed out on the Aussie XI

How did Simpson make it over him... Also this reminds me of Hayden and Greenidge who are up there with these guys as well

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Jaiswal is better than all of these guys

 

[Thala_0710]

Barry over Boycott is the equivalent of picking Van Der Bijl over Rabada, Les Jackson over Statham or Rajinder Goel over Anil Kumble.

You put Barry in your 4th....its not that bad

 

[Johan]

How did Simpson make it over him... Also this reminds of Hayden and Greenidge who are up there with these guys as well

Classic Lazy CW analysis.

 

[Thala_0710]

Jaiswal is better than all of these guys

Hutton is losing his spot by the time he's done

 

[sayon basak]

Barry over Boycott is the equivalent of picking Van Der Bijl over Rabada, Les Jackson over Statham or Rajinder Goel over Anil Kumble.

Van Der Bijl>Rabada. Goel was good, but no. Don't get the Les Jackson Glaze.

 

[capt_Luffy]

How did Simpson make it over him... Also this reminds of Hayden and Greenidge who are up there with these guys as well

A real tragedy really..... Had I been incharged back then I would had thrown a fit likely.

 

[Thala_0710]

Viv's in the lead!!!
McGrath has sealed his win as well

 

[Johan]

You put Barry in your 4th....its not that bad

I'd put Van Der Bijl over the Morkels, Ngidis, Burgers and maybe even Philanders of the world. But No, never would I put him over someone like an elite ATVG or ATG career, like Rabada, or Boycott.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Viv back in the lead and McGrath looking safe again

 

[Thala_0710]

I'd put Van Der Bijl over the Morkels, Ngidis, Burgers and maybe even Philanders of the world. But No, never would I put him over someone like an elite ATVG or ATG career, like Rabada, or Boycott.

Boycott's not that clear of guys like Greenidge, Hayden, Smith etc

 

[Johan]

Van Der Bijl>Rabada.

Yeah, No.

 

[Johan]

Boycott's not that clear of guys like Greenidge, Hayden, Smith etc

I'd put him closer to Gavaskar than to that Rabble

 

[Thala_0710]

I'd put him closer to Gavaskar than to that Rabble

That's simply.. Not true

 

[kyear2]

Nah I'd probably go like

Hobbs
Hutton

Gavaskar
Grace

Sutcliffe
Boycott

Trumper
Richards

Trumper and Barry sounds cool, Your guy and Kyear's guy, maybe a PC thread idea...

Swap the 3rd and 4th.

 

[kyear2]

Barry over Boycott is the equivalent of picking Van Der Bijl over Rabada, Les Jackson over Statham or Rajinder Goel over Anil Kumble.

Except that Barry is better than Boycott.