Elite Pacers vs Batters vs Spinners vs ARs - Who ranks highest in your top tier list?

[ataraxia]

wtf why are there two of these threads

AR >>>>>

Spinner >= pacer >>> batter

 

[subshakerz]

wtf why are there two of these threads

AR >>>>>

Sorry it got repeated by accident and I can't delete the first.

 

[kyear2]

An all rounder is only as good as his primary skill. An average batsman and bowler doesn't move the needle for me

 

[ataraxia]

An all rounder is only as good as his primary skill. An average batsman and bowler doesn't move the needle for me

It's not often a poster states something so utterly incorrect.

 

[kyear2]

It's not often a poster states something so utterly incorrect.

An average batsman and bowler vs an ATG batsman or bowler, which would you prefer in your team?

Let's go to the extreme

Would you prefer Kapil or even Botham

Or Marshall or McGrath?

Sachin or Sobers (if he wasn't bowling)

If you could even have two in by current WI team, I'm taking a bowler and one of the batsmen

 

[ataraxia]

I would likely prefer Trevor Goddard over Tendulkar-as-a-bat (who I consider tied second with Hobbs)