chaminda_00 said:
I think you will find that countries would pick their second best all rounder to fill this role, or the best all rounder not in their 1st XI. The guys that will fill the role for each side IMO:
Australia - S Waston
Sri Lanka - G Wijekoon
England - V Solanki (he will come on for guys like Jones once they bowled or Strauss once he bats)
South Africa - A Hall
West Indies - M Samuels
New Zealand - A Adams
Pakistan - Azhar Mahmood
India - A Agarkar
One option teams might use is go in with an extra batsmen and have a bowling all rounder as 12th man.
Why? Think about it... England pick Solanki and bat first, Brett Lee cleans up Andrew Strauss, and he is replaced with Vikram Solanki... who now cannot bat as he has already been dismissed, and isn't much of a bowler anyway!
The best thing would be to pick a specialist bat who also excels in the field... for example Brad Hodge or Michael Hussey.
Scenario: Australia picks all five specialist bowlers in their team, in Hogg, Kasprowicz, McGrath, Gillespie and Lee, and wins the toss and bowls. Glenn McGrath sends down his 10 overs straight up, leaves the field and is replaced with Hodge, who excels in the field, cutting off runs and so on. When Austrlaia bats, they have 7 specialist batsmen, plus a couple of bowlers who can bat a bit.
Alternative scenario: Australia picks the same team (or Watson instead of Kasprowicz would be fine too), but loses the toss, and is sent in to bat. If Australia is going along fine and bats out their 50 overs without losing more than 5 or 6 wickets, Hussey/Hodge stays in the pavilion and takes no part in the game until a bowler who is weak in the field is bowled out. If Australia get 5 or 6 down and need a batsmen, the switch is made for Australia's weakest seamer... probably Michael Kasprowicz. Hodge/Hussey can then bat and field, and Australia will need to send down 10 overs from Symonds and Clarke.
Therefore, my Australian team for the first NWC game:
Hayden
Gilchrist
Ponting
Martyn
Symonds
Clarke
Hogg
Lee
Gillespie
Kasprowicz (or Watson)
McGrath
Substitute: Michael Hussey