Jeffrey Dujon VS Adam Gilchrist

[Cricket Bliss]

Just based on their primary discipline

 

[capt_Luffy]

Gilchrist as he kept to Warne and MacGill. Dujon was ATG vs pace, but I rate keeping to spinners much higher.

 

[sayon basak]

Gilchrist as he kept to Warne and MacGill. Dujon was ATG vs pace, but I rate keeping to spinners much higher.

Therefore applying that keeping is the primary discipline of keepers??? Thus contradicting your 40-60????

There's no escape from this. Any last words???

 

[Qlder]

I think Dujon was just as good against pace as Healy (not Dujon's fault he didn't keep to an ATG spinner) and Healy was better than Gilchrist so I'm going Dujon

 

[capt_Luffy]

Therefore applying that keeping is the primary discipline of keepers??? Thus contradicting your 40-60????

There's no escape from this. Any last words???

Keeping is the primary discipline, but less important than batting after a nominal threshold

 

[Coronis]

Someone should find videos of Harper bowling and Dujon keeping to him.

Harper took 45 wickets with Dujon in the lineup. Dujon took 5 catches and 2 stumpings off him.