Everton Weekes vs Shivnarine Chanderpaul

[MasterBlaster24]

.

 

[Johan]

Weekes by far.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Like how come it's even a Convo??

 

[kyear2]

Weekes by far.

And easily

 

[Coronis]

Shiv and its not close

 

[Johan]

Shiv and its not close

Terrible, absolutely Terrible.

 

[DrWolverine]

 

[Johan]

in top 10 West Indies batsmen, Weekes is about 5, behind Viv, Sobers, Lara and Headley in that order.

Chanderpaul does not and will not ever make top 10.

 

[kyear2]

Shiv and its not close

How please...

 

[kyear2]

in top 10 West Indies batsmen, Weekes is about 5, behind Viv, Sobers, Lara and Headley in that order.

Chanderpaul does not and will not ever make top 10.

Basically

 

[Coronis]

How please...

Better records in and against the strongest teams of his time, carried a team on his back for the better part of a decade, better to watch.

 

[Johan]

Better records in and against the strongest teams of his time, carried a team on his back for the better part of a decade, better to watch.

so is Kevin Pietersen also better than Everton Weekes? also, the guy who voted Yousuf over Gower has no job talking about performance against best teams

 

[Coronis]

so is Kevin Pietersen also better than Everton Weekes? also, the guy who voted Yousuf over Gower has no job talking about performance against best teams

No, Pietersen is not. And yes, MoYo is better than Gower, get over it.

 

[Johan]

No, Pietersen is not. And yes, MoYo is better than Gower, get over it.

Why not? he averages 45 vs Australia and South Africa and 48 vs Murali Sri Lanka IE the three best bowling lineups of his time, Weekes 39 vs Australia and 45 vs England IE the two best bowling lineups of his era, KP better?

it's self contradictory, Gower averages 45 vs Australia, 33 vs West Indies (43 in WI) and 49 vs Pakistan IE the three best of his time, Moyo 29 vs all three of his time. Yet somehow MoYo is better...bias?

 

[Coronis]

Why not? he averages 45 vs Australia and South Africa and 48 vs Murali Sri Lanka IE the three best bowling lineups of his time, Weekes 39 vs Australia and 45 vs England IE the two best bowling lineups of his era, KP better?

it's self contradictory, Gower averages 45 vs Australia, 33 vs West Indies (43 in WI) and 49 vs Pakistan IE the three best of his time, Moyo 29 vs all three of his time. Yet somehow MoYo is better...bias?

Obviously they’re not the only measures lol.

 

[Johan]

Obviously they’re not the only measures lol.

Gower also played for a weaker unit than MoYo, who had Younis and Inzi, another point for David.

 

[Coronis]

Gower also played for a weaker unit than MoYo, who had Younis and Inzi, another point for David.

Oh please, Gower had Boycott and Gooch.

 

[Johan]

Oh please, Gower had Boycott and Gooch.

Boycott dissapeared like 3 years in his career lol, and you don't rate Gooch.

 

[Coronis]

Boycott dissapeared like 3 years in his career lol, and you don't rate Gooch.

But u do. And you also don’t rate Younis.. so…

 

[Johan]

But u do. And you also don’t rate Younis.. so…

did I ever say Gooch>Younis