Boycott vs Trumper

[kyear2]

Tell me, how come peer ratings don't work for Trumper??

I don't know how many times you want me to repeat that I don't especially rate players from before the first war.

Hobbs, due to his peer rating, being so far ahead of his peers and continuing on after the war, is the exception.

 

[sayon basak]

I don't know how many times you want me to repeat that I don't especially rate players from before the first war.

Hobbs, due to his peer rating, being so far ahead of his peers and continuing on after the war, is the exception.

If you don't rate pre war players, how did you compare Trumper with Boycott? Shouldn't you have refrained from voting?

 

[kyear2]

If you don't rate pre war players, how did you compare Trumper with Boycott? Shouldn't you have refrained from voting?

If I rate one and not the other, would the one I rate not be the one I vote for?

 

[Coronis]

If I rate one and not the other, would the one I rate not be the one I vote for?

You could always abstain and not post or vote in a thread about a pre-war player if you wanted

 

[kyear2]

You could always abstain and not post or vote in a thread about a pre-war player if you wanted

Why would I choose to do that?

 

[Coronis]

Why would I choose to do that?

I mean, I just don’t understand the point of voting and posting that you don’t rate these players at all over and over. Especially when we already all know it.

Be a bit like if I rocked up to ODI threads and said I don’t rate ODIs.