fair enough and I'd agree that Sherlock & Ryder need more consecutive games b4 laying claim to squad selections, however how much more experience could the current internationals have had when making their debuts at 20 - 22 yrs??
I know stats are a bad basis, however just as an indicator.....
current stats:
Papps = 44 FC @ 37, 35 Shield @ 33;
McIntosh = 41 FC @ 39;
How = 21 FC @ 36, 24 Shield & 22;
Nichol = 26 FC @ 41, 19 Shield @ 20;
Taylor = 10 FC @ 27, 10 Shield @ 65;
Fulton = 19 FC @ 50, 22 Shield @ 39.
in comparisson:
Jones = 67 FC @ 32,
Cumming = 69 FC @ 35, 70 Shield @ 18;
Vincent = 50 FC @ 31, 114 Shield @ 25;
Styris = 62 FC @ 30, 149 Shield @ 29;
Oram = 40 FC @ 32, 110 Shield @ 24;
scott = 9 FC @ 26, 10 Shield @ 21;
Gillespie = 17 FC @ 23, 23 Shield @ 29;
B Martin = 41 FC @ 29, 30 Shield @ 25.
Taylor & Fulton have no more experience than the likes of Scott, and Gillespie has about the same exposure, yet you didn't challenge their naming..........