Current greats and all time greats

[Slifer]

Thread is self explanatory, which current players or recently retired would we consider greats and atgs.

 

[Johan]

ATGs if they retire today
Steven Smith
Joe Root
Jasprit Bumrah
Ravindra Jadeja
Kane Williamson

 

[Slifer]

ATGs if they retire today
Steven Smith
Joe Root
Jasprit Bumrah
Ravindra Jadeja
Kane Williamson

For me I'd go:

Bowlers

Ashwin
Cummins*
Rabada
Bumrah*
Anderson


Batsmen

Smith*
Kane
Root

AR & WK

Jadeja
Stokes
Pant

* = atg

 

[Thala_0710]

ATGs if they retire today
Steven Smith
Joe Root
Jasprit Bumrah
Ravindra Jadeja
Kane Williamson

KW's ahead of Cummins?

 

[Johan]

KW's ahead of Cummins?

I forgot about Cummins tbh, he gets in there.

KW is Rabada level

 

[Thala_0710]

I'll go for Smith, Root, Bumrah and Cummins as ATGs if they retired today and Rabada will get there by the end of his career.
Early shouts but Jaiswal, Brook and Jansen have a good chance of ending up in the list as well

 

[Coronis]

For me I'd go:

Bowlers

Ashwin
Cummins*
Rabada
Bumrah*
Anderson


Batsmen

Smith*
Kane
Root

AR & WK

Jadeja
Stokes
Pant

* = atg

What about Shakib?

 

[DrWolverine]

Test cricket

ATGs
Steven Smith
Jasprit Bumrah
Joe Root

Greats but not on their level
Virat Kohli
Kane Williamson
Pat Cummins
Kagiso Rabada
James Anderson

 

[Red]

I still think my metric of the definition of an ATG works pretty well. Would they make a NZ all time XI whether NZer or not.

 

[manoftommorow]

Batsmen
Steve Smith
Joe Root
Kane Williamson
Virat Kohli

Bowlers
Jasprit Bumrah
Pat Cummins
Kagiso Rabada
Mitchell Starc (Don't ask me)

All-Rounders
Ravindra Jadeja
Ben Stokes
Ravindra Ashwin
Shakib-ul-Hasan


Wicketkeeper's
Rishabh Pant
Mohammad Rizwan
Alex Carey
Tom Blundell?

 

[Mr Fahrenheit]

Shakin-ul-Hasan

Who up Shakin their ul-Hasan?

 

[manoftommorow]

Who up Shakin their ul-Hasan?

So who should be at 4?

 

[Mr Fahrenheit]

So who should be at 4?

Sakibul Hasan

 

[manoftommorow]

Oh now I understand xD

Sakibul Hasan

 

[capt_Luffy]

Batsmen:

Steve Smith
Joe Root
Kane Williamson
Virat Kohli


Bowlers:

Jasprit Bumrah
Pat Cummins
Kagiso Rabada
Ravichandran Ashwin
James Anderson


Allrounders:

Ravindra Jadeja
Ben Stokes
Shakib Al Hasan


Wicketkeepers:

Rishabh Pant


The ones I am willing to bet to end up as ATG are:

Marco Jansen
Harry Brook
Yashasvi Jaiswal


Outside shots:

Jamie Smith
Mohammad Rizwan
Washington Sundar

 

[Thala_0710]

Rachin Kamindu Seales Gill probably outside shouts as well for great status

 

[capt_Luffy]

Rachin Kamindu Seales Gill probably outside shouts as well for great status

Rachin and Kamindu quite Old, Seales too outside a shout atm, Gill Ze Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Haaaa

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Smith
Root
Williamson
Kohli
Bumrah
Cummins
Rabada

Brook
Jaiswal
Jansen

 

[Majestic]

ATGs-

Smith
Root

Bumrah
Cummins

Close to it but not there yet:

Rabada
Jadeja
Williamson

 

[govinda indian fan]

Present atgs
Steve smith
Joe root
Jasprit bumrah
Pat Cummins
Kg rabada
Ravi jadeja
Future atgs
Brook
Jansan
Jamie smith
Not sure about jaiswal as these days he is throwing his wicket trying to hit every ball for boundary