| Player | Match | Venue |
| Alec Bannerman | The Ashes: 3rd Test, 1888 | Old Trafford, Manchester |
| Percy McDonnell | ||
| Jack Fingleton | The Ashes: 1st Test, 1936/37 | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane |
| Jack Badcock | ||
| Bill O'Reilly | The Ashes: 3rd Test, 1936/37 | Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| Chuck Fleetwood-Smith | ||
| Arthur Morris | Australia in South Africa: 1st Test, 1949/50 | Ellis Park, Johannesburg |
| Jack Moroney | ||
| Michael Slater | Australia in Sri Lanka: 1st Test, 1999 | Asgiriya Stadium, Kandy |
| Greg Blewett |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Herbert Sutcliffe | New Zealand v England: 1st Test, 1932/33 | Lancaster Park, Christchurch |
| Eddie Paynter | ||
| Mike Denness | Pakistan v England: 2nd Test, 1972/73 | Niaz Stadium, Hyderabad, Sind |
| Dennis Amiss | ||
| Derek Randall | Australia v England: 1st Test, 1979/80 | W.A.C.A. Ground, Perth |
| Geoff Boycott | ||
| Graham Gooch | The Wisden Trophy: 1st Test, 1985/86 | Sabina Park, Kingston, Jamaica |
| Tim Robinson | ||
| Marcus Trescothick | England in Pakistan: 2nd Test, 2005/06 | Iqbal Stadium, Faisalabad |
| Andrew Strauss |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Pankaj Roy | England v India: 1st Test, 1952 | Headingley, Leeds |
| Datta Gaekwad | ||
| Motganhalli Jaisimha | India v Australia: 1st Test, 1964/65 | Corporation Stadium, Madras |
| Prince Indrajitsinhji | ||
| Sunny Gavaskar | Australia v India: 3rd Test, 1977/78 | Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| Chetan Chauhan | ||
| Nayan Mongia | India in Zimbabwe: Only Test, 1998/99 | Harare Sports Club |
| Navjot Sidhu | ||
| Devang Gandhi | New Zealand in India: 1st Test, 1999/00 | Punjab C.A. Stadium, Mohali, Chandigarh |
| Sadagoppan Ramesh |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Noel McGregor | South Africa v New Zealand: 4th Test, 1961/62 | New Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg |
| Graham Dowling | ||
| Terry Jarvis | New Zealand v England: 3rd Test, 1965/66 | Eden Park, Auckland |
| Mike Shrimpton | ||
| Michael Papps | New Zealand in South Africa: 3rd Test, 2005/06 | New Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg |
| Jamie How |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Shafiq Ahmed | Pakistan v West Indies: 3rd Test, 1980/81 | National Stadium, Karachi |
| Sadiq Mohammad | ||
| Mudassar Nazar | Australia v Pakistan: 1st Test, 1981/82 | W.A.C.A. Ground, Perth |
| Rizwan-uz-Zaman | ||
| Mohsin Khan | England v Pakistan: 3rd Test, 1982 | Headingley, Leeds |
| Mudassar Nazar | ||
| Shakeel Ahmed | West Indies v Pakistan: 3rd Test, 1992/93 | Antigua Recreation Ground, St John's, Antigua |
| Rameez Raja | ||
| Imran Nazir | Australia v Pakistan Test Series: 1st Test, 2002/03 | P.Saravanamuttu Stadium, Colombo |
| Taufeeq Umar | ||
| Imran Nazir | Australia v Pakistan Test Series: 2nd Test, 2002/03 | Sharjah C.A. Stadium |
| Taufeeq Umar |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Jackie McGlew | England v South Africa: 2nd Test, 1955 | Lord's, London |
| Trevor Goddard | ||
| Gary Kirsten | South Africa in Sri Lanka: 2nd Test, 2000 | Asgiriya Stadium, Kandy |
| Neil McKenzie | ||
| Herschelle Gibbs | South Africa in Sri Lanka: 2nd Test, 2006 | P.Saravanamuttu Stadium, Colombo |
| Andrew Hall |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Sidath Wettimuny | Sri Lanka v Australia: Only Test, 1982/83 | Asgiriya Stadium, Kandy |
| Susil Fernando | ||
| Roshan Mahanama | Sri Lanka v South Africa: 2nd Test, 1993 | Sinhalese Sports Club Ground, Colombo |
| Chandika Hathurusingha | ||
| Marvan Atapattu | South Africa in Sri Lanka: 2nd Test, 2000 | Asgiriya Stadium, Kandy |
| Sanath Jayasuriya | ||
| Marvan Atapattu | Sri Lanka in South Africa: 1st Test, 2000/01 | Kingsmead, Durban |
| Sanath Jayasuriya |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| George Challenor | England v West Indies: 2nd Test, 1928 | Old Trafford, Manchester |
| Clifford Roach | ||
| Conrad Hunte | West Indies v Pakistan: 5th Test, 1957/58 | Queen's Park Oval, Port of Spain, Trinidad |
| Rohan Kanhai | ||
| John Holt | India v West Indies: 2nd Test, 1958/59 | Green Park, Kanpur |
| Conrad Hunte | ||
| Alvin Greenidge | India v West Indies: 1st Test, 1978/79 | Wankhede Stadium, Bombay |
| Basil Williams | ||
| Gordon Greenidge | West Indies v India: 2nd Test, 1982/83 | Queen's Park Oval, Port of Spain, Trinidad |
| Desmond Haynes |
| Player | Match | Venue |
| Grant Flower | Pakistan v Zimbabwe: 2nd Test, 1996/97 | Iqbal Stadium, Faisalabad |
| Mark Dekker | ||
| Neil Johnson | Zimbabwe in West Indies: 1st Test, 1999/00 | Queen's Park Oval, Port of Spain, Trinidad |
| Grant Flower |
