The Green Thread

[steds]

I want to play for Green.

 

[Robertinho]

Well as far as the league is concerned, once a player commits to a club, he/she has signed on for the season. Otherwise it can be hell for a club to organize its squad list heading into next season. Consider that if we do it your way, all the players Black has signed can theoretically jump ship the day before the season starts.

Camps, surely Dunn can leave if he wants... him simply saying "Ok I'll stay" isn't binding at all.

 

[marc71178]

Yes, he can leave if Blue get someone in exchange.

 

[Robertinho]

Why? The season hasn't started, he isn't bound by the conditions that are in place during a season.

 

[AussieDominance]

Good to have you aboard Matt.

Welcome Matt as well.

 

[pasag]

This is farcical, putting down your name in a thread is just a common courtesy to the captain and the team and should not be binding in nature as all.

 

[Robertinho]

I've just had an extensive chat with Garven over this, and I thought I'd summarise my thoughts here -

- There is nothing to suggest that Pinchy's response to Liam's post with "I'll Stay" was binding - or the equivalent of being officially contracted (ie; his position in the squad being finalised in the Squad Announcements thread)
- According to Garven, Liam then decided after Pinchy had responded that it would be binding
- Therefore, the pretenses under which Pinchy said he'd stay were false, because there was no indication UPON SIGNING that it'd be binding

I think that whilst it's inconvenient and undesireable for Blue that Pinchy should change his mind after saying that he'd stay (and I sympathise in this regard), there are no grounds for him to be barred from moving.

Don't mean to annoy anyone, and I didn't really care much about this, but Garven has compelled me to offer my thoughts. Could be misinformed though, so apologies if I've missed something.

Edit - might also add that Garven doesn't actually intend to sign Pinchy, so feel free to come Red bud .

 

[Matteh]

- There is nothing to suggest that Pinchy's response to Liam's post with "I'll Stay" was binding - or the equivalent of being officially contracted (ie; his position in the squad being finalised in the Squad Announcements thread)
- According to Garven, Liam then decided after Pinchy had responded that it would be binding
- Therefore, the pretenses under which Pinchy said he'd stay were false, because there was no indication UPON SIGNING that it'd be binding

Think this should set the future precedent.

 

[AussieDominance]

Mitchell can you give everyone an updated contract list

 

[Matteh]

Updated list:
M Mitchell
N Dravid
J Rodgie
A Garven
A Lezama
M Pitt
X Rose
N Scott
R Malone

Was on the previous page. Am led to believe that's it so far.

 

[bugssy]

im here boys and i am commiting my future to the greens. i am also commiting my future to the captain and putting my hand up for vc if he would like. if it has been handed out all ready than fantastic and congrats.

i would also like to welcome the new team mates and a warm welcome to one of the greatest clubs around.

 

[AussieDominance]

Updated list:
M Mitchell
N Dravid
J Rodgie
A Garven
A Lezama
M Pitt
X Rose
N Scott
R Malone

Was on the previous page. Am led to believe that's it so far.

Cheers,

btw whats ur MSN?

need to tell you something

 

[Matteh]

That would be: mtm_01@hotmail.com

 

[marc71178]

Why? The season hasn't started, he isn't bound by the conditions that are in place during a season.

He has committed himself to the club.

There has to be some cap on it, otherwise players could all up and leave on the last day of the pre-season and leave a club with 3 or 4 players.

 

[Matteh]

Pre-season activity check?

 

[age_master]

He has committed himself to the club.

There has to be some cap on it, otherwise players could all up and leave on the last day of the pre-season and leave a club with 3 or 4 players.

Dauth has commitment problems it seems

 

[Matteh]

Dauth has commitment problems it seems

What's his MSN?

 

[Robertinho]

He has committed himself to the club.

There has to be some cap on it, otherwise players could all up and leave on the last day of the pre-season and leave a club with 3 or 4 players.

It isn't as though Pinchy is a group of 5 players who left suddenly on the eve of the beginning of the season proper. He's one guy, who left weeeell before the season is even close to starting. Not going to bother with Garven's comment either, as it's not really funny or relevant.

 

[age_master]

It isn't as though Pinchy is a group of 5 players who left suddenly on the eve of the beginning of the season proper. He's one guy, who left weeeell before the season is even close to starting. Not going to bother with Garven's comment either, as it's not really funny or relevant.

If you have a problem with Liam's decision i suggest you take it up with him or through the PA rep.

Please do not post in this thread again.

 

[bugssy]

you want my msn lol!