• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Cricket players as tennis players

_00_deathscar

International Regular
Who would be comparable to who?
What surfaces are comparable to certain pitches/conditions in cricket and who dominates where?

Go.
 
I will just go on modern day players.


Smith is like Djokovic.Not the best to watch but a machine.Comparable mental strength.
Smith would win most GS.Would be dominant in US Open,AUS open and probably even in grass.Would likely win few RG as well.

Kohli would win most RG,4-5.And likely win AUS Open,US Open but the main challenge for him would be to win in grass.

Root would win few GS in grass and may pull 1-2 GS in clay.Would probably not win any GS in AUS Open or US Open.

Williamson despite being one of the best in this era hasn’t done anything outside NZ.May win few slams but idk.
 
Last edited:

Xuhaib

International Coach
Modern loi hacks like Roy etc similar to 90's Wimbledon bullies who would get a decent tournament run due to their huge first serve but had little else to their game to do well all year around.
 

Godard

U19 Vice-Captain
Tendulkar would pick a cricket elbow injury and suck for 5 years.
Tendulkar sucked for like 12 matches from Ind vs Sl 2005-06 till ind vs sa 2006-07. In the 172 matches from. 1993-2011, he only had something like a slump in these matches. Somehow people have this idea that he sucked for 2002-2007. During this period he averaged close to 49.
 

ankitj

Hall of Fame Member
Tendulkar sucked for like 12 matches from Ind vs Sl 2005-06 till ind vs sa 2006-07. In the 172 matches from. 1993-2011, he only had something like a slump in these matches. Somehow people have this idea that he sucked for 2002-2007. During this period he averaged close to 49.
Between Multan test against Pakistan in 2004 and 2007-08 tour of Australia, Tendulkar played something like 30-40 tests in memory. Outside of Bangladesh, he scored just one hundred against SL and averaged 33 or so (averaged 150-200 against BD in the period). Somehow people just look at overall averages and have the idea that he didn't really suck in that period. He sucked at same level as current Kohli.
 

ankitj

Hall of Fame Member
this is a massive exaggeration
I remeber being very very frustrated at many of his batting failures including not playing according to demands of the situation. His best however in that period was his fifty on treacherous Mumbai pitch against Australia in 2004.
 

Godard

U19 Vice-Captain
Between Multan test against Pakistan in 2004 and 2007-08 tour of Australia, Tendulkar played something like 30-40 tests in memory. Outside of Bangladesh, he scored just one hundred against SL and averaged 33 or so (averaged 150-200 against BD in the period). Somehow people just look at overall averages and have the idea that he didn't really suck in that period. He sucked at same level as current Kohli.
First of all this is a highly selective sample, and further you are excluding tests against Ban. Agreed they were a very poor test team, but Tendu shouldn’t get penalised for scoring heavily against them in this period. I don’t think it’s fair to say a player sucked if for a period for 25(30-4 or 5 he played against Ban), he averaged 33 against major nations. Plus if you look closely, after Ind vs Pak series, Tendulkar sucked for two two match series vs Aus and Sa, then had a great series vs Ban and a good one vs Pak, where he averaged 50+ and scored 3 fifties including a score of 94. Now comes a slump, a continuous spell of bad form where he had those 12 bad matches I have mentioned above. After this good series vs Pak and great vs Aus.
 

Top