Nikhil's Hindi movie ratings

[NikhilN]

Just like my song ratings I will rate movies.


Ratings will be given on Story and nothing else


Movie 1: Nayak

Rating: 9/10


Movie 2: Kal Ho Na Ho

Rating 10/10


Movie 3: Koi Mil Gaya

Rating 10/10


Movie 4: Munna Bhai MBBS

Rating 8/10


More to come

[Sudeep]

Movie 1: Nayak

Rating: 9/10


Movie 2: Kal Ho Na Ho

Rating 10/10


Movie 3: Koi Mil Gaya

Rating 10/10


Movie 4: Munna Bhai MBBS

Rating 8/10

Too high ratings.

Wouldn't rate any of the four above 8.

[NikhilN]

I am going with story line and nothing else...

[Deja moo]

Koi Mil Gaya is a rip off of ET and Forrest Gump , and has a very unconvincing end .

It doesnt deserve more than a 5 based on story line alone.

Munnabhai MBBS is way ahead of Kal ho na ho in terms of storyline.
Kal ho na ho is nothing but " Anand " ( old hindi movie ) set in New York.

[V Reddy]

Koi Mil Gaya is a rip off of ET and Forrest Gump , and has a very unconvincing end .

Most Hindi films are a rip off of South Indian and Hollywood movies. Nayak is a remake too

[Deja moo]

Most Hindi films are a rip off of South Indian and Hollywood movies. Nayak is a remake too

Yeah, but Nayak wasnt pretentious in that the same people made the two versions.

KMG was made ( rather ripped off ) and the director refused to acknowledge the fact.

same with KHNH.

[masterblaster]

Ill give you mine:

Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikandar - 9/10

Lagaan - 9/10

Dil Chahta Hai - 9/10

(Can you tell im a bit of an Aamir Khan Fan?)

Ab tak Chappan (Gangster movie) - 8/10

Company - 9/10

Legend of Bhagat Singh (With Ajay Devgan) - 8.5/10

Yes Boss (With Shah Rukh Khan) - 8/10

Andaz Apna Apna (Aamir Khan/Salman Khan) - 9/10 (Brilliant and extremely funny!)

Bhoot - 7/10

Munnabhai MBBS - 6/10 (An okay movie, but pretty lame for the most of it)

Koi Mil Gaya - 7/10 (pretty good, but a rip off of ET and Forrest Gump)

Kal Ho Na Ho - 7/10 (Okay, but Anand with Rajesh Khanna and Amitabh Bachchan was better)

Ill rate some more later

[Sudeep]

As I said in the favorite movies thread, my favorite Hindi movies are Lagaan, Dil Chahta Hai and Hera Pheri.

Lagaan - 9

Dil Chahta Hai - 9

Hera Pheri - 9.5

Jo Jeeta Wahi Sikander - 8.5

Sarfarosh - 8.5

All other movies according to me would be 8 or below.

[Sudeep]

Watched Main Hoon Na a couple of days back.

Kind of humbug, but an all fun, time pass movie.

Would rate it 8-ish.

[Sudeep]

Ill give you mine:
Yes Boss (With Shah Rukh Khan) - 8/10

Andaz Apna Apna (Aamir Khan/Salman Khan) - 9/10 (Brilliant and extremely funny!)

Munnabhai MBBS - 6/10 (An okay movie, but pretty lame for the most of it)

My ratings:

Yes Boss and Andaz Apna Apna were good, would get an 8 rating from me.

I don't rate Munnabhai MBBS highly. Not the kind of movie I'll pay to watch. Watched it only in bits and pieces, and would rate it 5.

[Sudeep]

Hey, where did my sig go in the above post?

EDIT: Remember now, only one sig per post, isn't it?

[Sudeep]

Another movie I rate very highly is "Aankhen."

Not the one with Govinda and Chunky Pande. But with Paresh Rawal, Amitabh Bhacchan, Akshay Kumar and Arjun Rampal.

[masterblaster]

Govinda and Chunky Pandey **shudders in pain**

Yes the one with Paresh Rawal, Amitabh Bachchan, Akshay Kumar, Arjun Rampal and Sushmita Sen was very good.

Very, very good. 8/10 for me.

[chicane]

I watch very few Hindi movies but am pretty up to date with the buzz thanks to my sis.
My ratings, based purely on how much I liked the film -

Dil Chahta Hai - 9/10

The Legand Of Bhagat Singh - 9/10

Lagaan - 9/10

Hera Pheri - 8/10

Aawara Paagal Deewana - 8/10

Company - 8/10

Hungama - 7/10

Judwaa - 7/10

Satya - 6/10

Fiza - 6/10

I think I'll go watch Lakshya and Yuva.

[Sudeep]

I watch very few Hindi movies but am pretty up to date with the buzz thanks to my sis.
My ratings, based purely on how much I liked the film -

The Legand Of Bhagat Singh - 9/10

Aawara Paagal Deewana - 8/10

Hungama - 7/10

I think I'll go watch Lakshya and Yuva.

I agree with your ratings for APD and Hungama.

However, I don't think The Legend of Bhagat Singh was that good a movie. I would give it 7.5 or something. It was better than the other one on Bhagat Singh, but apart from Ajay Devgan's portrayal of Bhagat Singh, the movie had quite a bit of flaws.