All-Time World XIs: Discussion Thread

[Coronis]

Bradman

Knott

Marshall
McGrath

You may want to update the XI in your signature.

 

[kyear2]

You may want to update the XI in your signature.

So do you?

Bradman
Gilchrist
Hadlee
McGrath

Alright.



So I’ve made some recent changes.



I will also be posting my top 20 bowlers list.







McGrath

Marshall

Hadlee

Muralitharan

Warne

Steyn

Ambrose

Imran

Barnes

O’Reilly

Wasim

Donald

Davidson

Garner

Lindwall

Lillee

Holding

Trueman

Pollock

Waqar



Enjoy

And your ranking order as well?

 

[sayon basak]

So do you?





And your ranking order as well?

Don't get what this post is getting at. He rates McGrath as the best ever, and might have Hadlee higher in a team overall. Whereas you chose Knott while having Gilchrist in your XI which is visible just below your posts.

 

[capt_Luffy]

So do you?





And your ranking order as well?

Like, he has both McGrath and Hadlee in his XI

 

[kyear2]

Don't get what this post is getting at. He rates McGrath as the best ever, and might have Hadlee higher in a team overall. Whereas you chose Knott while having Gilchrist in your XI which is visible just below your posts.

Higher how?

If it's based on bowling it's McGrath and Marshall, it it's based on batting it's Marshall and Hadlee, in any event. Just asked a question.

I have had multiple conversations recently when I said I was voting for Knott this time around.

I think it was around two weeks ago, you're free to check.

 

[kyear2]

Don't get what this post is getting at. He rates McGrath as the best ever, and might have Hadlee higher in a team overall. Whereas you chose Knott while having Gilchrist in your XI which is visible just below your posts.

And it's one I have 0 issue with.



He might even get my vote in the upcoming thread. Not as a sympathy vote, but he's legitimately an AT keeper and was good enough with the bat

 

[sayon basak]

Higher how?

If it's based on bowling it's McGrath and Marshall, it it's based on batting it's Marshall and Hadlee, in any event. Just asked a question.

I have had multiple conversations recently when I said I was voting for Knott this time around.

I think it was around two weeks ago, you're free to check.

BTW if you look at his team which is visible below his posts, he has all 3 pacers in his XI.

Question:- Which keeper do you have in your team?

 

[sayon basak]

.

That means you now have Knott in your XI ahead of Gilly. So, shouldn't you update your signature?

 

[Thala_0710]

That means you now have Knott in your XI ahead of Gilly. So, shouldn't you update your signature?

Am I the only one who doesn't know what signature is being talked about?

 

[sayon basak]

Am I the only one who doesn't know what signature is being talked about?

Probably.

 

[Thala_0710]

Probably.

Educate me please

 

[capt_Luffy]

Educate me please

Never used Laptop to surf CW??

 

[Thala_0710]

Never used Laptop to surf CW??

Nope

 

[capt_Luffy]

Nope

Click my profile and go to about. You can see my signature. In computer, it's visible below every post. So yeah, can also just turn on Desktop site for a few mins and will get everything.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Lol I had a habit of surfing CW in labs when prof looked bored. Not even sure have cleared history everytime.

 

[kyear2]

So we didn't select the best new ball bowler of all time and the bowler consistently chosen as the 2nd best bowler of all time

Why?

He couldn't bat.

But doesn't he bat no. 11?

Yup.

And aren't there the best batsmen in the world above him?

Yup.

The actual ****

 

[Coronis]

Nope

Or you can simply scroll in landscape mode.

BTW if you look at his team which is visible below his posts, he has all 3 pacers in his XI.

Question:- Which keeper do you have in your team?

So we didn't select the best new ball bowler of all time and the bowler consistently chosen as the 2nd best bowler of all time

Why?

He couldn't bat.

But doesn't he bat no. 11?

Yup.

And aren't there the best batsmen in the world above him?

Yup.

The actual ****

Why do you ignore a simple question @kyear2 is Knott in your all time XI or not?

 

[Fuller Pilch]

So we didn't select the best new ball bowler of all time and the bowler consistently chosen as the 2nd best bowler of all time

Why?

He couldn't bat.

But doesn't he bat no. 11?

Yup.

And aren't there the best batsmen in the world above him?

Yup.

The actual ****

Those evil Kiwis are up to no good and forced CW voters to choose that Hadlee bloke.

 

[PlayerComparisons]

The voting for the third pace bowler is going to be painful for kyear

 

[Bolo.]

But doesn't he bat no. 11?

Chris Martin is a better bowler than Sobers. If we are picking a bowler, might as well pick Martin. The quality of Sobers' batting clearly doesn't count cos Martin batted at 11.

Or we could consider the batting of both people when making a comparison between them?