Who would you prefer - Aguero, Rooney or Suarez?

[Nate]

Was thinking about this today. All play a similar role, but each offer something a bit different.

 

[flibbertyjibber]

For now i'd say Rooney as he is proven over time in the Premier League. That may change though in a year or so if Aguero keeps up to anything like the standard he is at present. Suarez is just a good player in comparison to the other two in my opinion.

If it was a general point and not aimed at Prem then Aguero.

 

[MW1304]

Hard to split Rooney and Aguero on current form. Suarez has a bit more to prove than them at top club level.

 

[Cevno]

Rooney,IMO.

More complete player than the other 2. Can create goals, score goals, be the playmaker, Track back/tackle. Even more crucial to United this season.

 

[Redbacks]

If it was a general point and not aimed at Prem then Aguero.

For that reason I voted Suarez. He has stood out at a Copa America in a winning team, good at the WC and he can keep goal

Rooney is the proven BPL star.

 

[Furball]

 

[flibbertyjibber]

Pub leagues don't count.

 

[cpr]

Dunno TBH, obviously Rooney is flying in the Prem, never really stood up at a big tourney, mainly due to injuries and the issue of having to play with 10 other Englishmen.


Aguero in the Prem is just scaring me....... Please send him back!

 

[Uppercut]

Not his biggest fan by any means but it has to be Roon. The fact that he feels about ten years older than the other two when there's only a couple of years between the three says a lot about what they've achieved in their respective careers.

 

[Pothas]

Yeah cannot really argue with Rooney but would still take Aguero, the way he is settling is ridiculously impressive.

 

[BoyBrumby]

Dunno TBH, obviously Rooney is flying in the Prem, never really stood up at a big tourney, mainly due to injuries and the issue of having to play with 10 other Englishmen.


Aguero in the Prem is just scaring me....... Please send him back!

Had a great Euro 2004, tbh. All went Pete Tong when he broke his metatarsal.

Have Suarez and Aguero in my DT but not Rooney fwiw.

 

[Jarquis]

I got Suarez and Rooney, there's a reason that hardly anyone has Aguero + Rooney and it's because Suarez is valued about £3m less than those two.
There's a reason for that too..

 

[Furball]

Aguero, Rooney and Dzeko for the win.

Also managed to nab Silva for my midfield as well.

I'd have Suarez at the bottom of the 3 mentioned, I think he's a great player but he's also over-rated.

For the Premiership, I'd pick Rooney purely on the basis of past experience and performance. If I was playing Football Manager and had the money, I'd buy Aguero every single time.

 

[Pothas]

Aguero, Rooney and Dzeko for the win.

Also managed to nab Silva for my midfield as well.

Is the rest of the side all from Swansea?