• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Rugby Union All-Time Draft

Francis

State Vice-Captain
Graham Mourie, to me, represents New Zealand rugby better than anybody else. The phrase "hard but fair" has become overused and worn out, but it applies to Mourie. Gareth Edwards once said Mourie's real greatness was that he had an appreciation of rugby's unwritten rules and understood perfectly where hard, committed play stops short of being dirty. I love this quote from Mourie, "The whole basis is enjoyment. The more often you win, the greater the enjoyment, but never a win at all costs." Unfortunately players like Andy Hayden (I hate him so much) and John Ashworth couldn't follow the lead.

Aside from being a terrific captain who could make his team rise to whatever occasion, he was also a devilish strategist. Mourie knew, in 1982, that Mark Ella wanted Mourie to tackle him. Mourie's aim was to make Mark Ella think he was going to tackle him by running a different angle towards him, herding Ella back towards the forwards. There were times where it looked as if Ella had stepped Mourie, but then Cowboy Shaw would come across to nail him! Mourie just had a wonderful tactical outlook like that and his duel with Ella was a facinating cat and mouse battle.

In a world without evil, Graham Mourie and not the diabolical Colin Meads, would be the most celebrated All Black.
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
You kidding me aren't. Your giving him 24 hours to make a pick. Just make a pick and keep this moving Somerset.
 

99*

International Debutant
Fergus Slattery
Bastard just noticed you pick him. ARGH!

In that case I'll take, Sir William Wavell Wakefield, 1st Baron Wakefield of Kendal.

That sorts out my back row.

Code:
1- 
2- P. Kearns
3- 
4- 
5- C. Meads
6- W. Wakefield
7- J. Prat
8- W. Shelford
9- 
10- H. Porta
11-
12-
13-
14-
15- A. Irvine
 

Somerset

Cricketer Of The Year
Round One
Michaelf7777777 - Grant Fox (#10)
Somerset - Daniel Carter (#10)
99* - Colin Meads (#5)
Perm - Richie McCaw (#7)
Voltman - Michael Jones (#7)
Simon - John Eales (#5)
Indipper - Frik du Preez (#5)
Jamee999 - Jonah Lomu (#11)
Francis - Zinzan Brooke (#8)
BoyBrumby - Barry John (#10)
Chaminda_00 - Sean Fitzpatrick (#2)
ripper868 - Nick Farr-Jones (#9)
ohtani's jacket - Graham Price (#3)

Round Two
ohtani's jacket - Robert Paparemborde (#1)
ripper868 - Keith Wood (#2)
Chaminda_00 - Os du Randt (#1)
BoyBrumby - Martin Johnson (#4)
Francis - Willie John McBride (#5)
Jamee999 - Bill Beaumont (#5)
Indipper - Ian McLauchlan (#1)
Simon - Joost van der Westhuizen (#9)
Voltman - Danie Gerber (#13)
Perm - Justin Marshall (#9)
99* - Wayne (Buck) Shelford (#8)
Somerset - George Nepia (#15)
Michaelf7777777 - David Campese (#11)

Round Three
Michaelf7777777 - Gareth Edwards (#9)
Somerset - Sir Brian Lochore (#8)
99* - Hugo Porta (#10)
Perm - JPR Williams (#15)
Voltman - Mike Gibson (#12)
Simon - Michael Lynagh (#10)
Indipper - Peter Wheeler (#2)
Jamee999 - George Smith (#7)
Francis - Gordon Brown (#4)
BoyBrumby - Tim Horan (#12)
Chaminda_00 - George Gregan (#9)
ripper868 - Phillippe Sella (#13)
ohtani's jacket - Hennie Muller (#8)

Round Four
ohtani's jacket - Mark Ella (#10)
ripper868 - Naas Botha (#10)
Chaminda_00 - Phil Bennett (#10)
BoyBrumby - Wilson Whineray (#1)
Francis - Cliff Morgan (#10)
Jamee999 - Jason Leonard (#1)
Indipper - Mervyn Davies (#8)
Simon - Matthew Burke (#15)
Voltman - Aaron "Okey" Geffin (#3)
Perm - Jeff Wilson (#14)
99* - Andy Irvine (#15)
Somerset - John Kirwan (#14)
Michaelf7777777 - Trevor Allan (#13)

Round Five
Michaelf7777777 - Kevin Skinner (#3)
Somerset - Jean-Pierre Rives (#6)
99* - Phil Kearns (#2)
Perm - Carl Hayman (#3)
Voltman - John Rutherford (#10)
Simon - Morne du Plessis (#8)
Indipper - Serge Blanco (#15)
Jamee999 - Lawrence Dallaglio (#8)
Francis - Ken Catchpole (#9)
BoyBrumby - Josh Kronfeld (#7)
Chaminda_00 - Francois Pienaar (#6)
ripper868 - Gavin Hastings (#15)
ohtani's jacket - Jan Lotz (#2)

Round Six
ohtani's jacket - Kel Tremain (#6)
ripper868 - Peter Winterbottom (#7)
Chaminda_00 - Ian Jones (#4)
BoyBrumby - Christian Cullen (#15)
Francis - Ian Kirkpatrick (#6)
Jamee999 - Bryan Habana (#14)
Indipper - Fergus Slattery (#7)
Simon - Joe Rokocoko (#11)
Voltman - Serafin Dengra (#1)
Perm -
99* - Jean Prat (#7)
Somerset - Graham Mourie (#7)
Michaelf7777777 - Maurice Brownlee (#8)

Round Seven
Michaelf7777777 - Rob McCall (#4/5)
Somerset - André Boniface (#13)
99* - Sir William Wavell Wakefield (#6)
Perm -
Voltman -
Simon -
Indipper -
Jamee999 -
Francis -
BoyBrumby -
Chaminda_00 -
ripper868 -
ohtani's jacket -

What countries did Maurice Brownlee and Rob McCall play for? Never heard of them before and can't find any sources on them.
 
Last edited:

Somerset

Cricketer Of The Year
Michaelf7777777
Kevin Skinner (#3)
Rob McCall (#4/5)
Maurice Brownlee (#8)
Gareth Edwards (#9)
Grant Fox (#10)
David Campese (#11)
Trevor Allan (#13)

Somerset
Jean-Pierre Rives (#6)
Graham Mourie (#7)
Sir Brian Lochore (#8)
Daniel Carter (#10)
André Boniface (#13)
John Kirwan (#14)
George Nepia (#15)

99*
Phil Kearns (#2)
Colin Meads (#5)
Sir William Wavell Wakefield (#6)
Jean Prat (#7)
Wayne (Buck) Shelford (#8)
Hugo Porta (#10)
Andy Irvine (#15)

Perm
Carl Hayman (#3)
Richie McCaw (#7)
Justin Marshall (#9)
Jeff Wilson (#14)
JPR Williams (#15)

Voltman
Serafin Dengra (#1)
Aaron "Okey" Geffin (#3)
Michael Jones (#7)
John Rutherford (#10)
Mike Gibson (#12)
Danie Gerber (#13)

Simon
John Eales (#5)
Morne du Plessis (#8)
Joost van der Westhuizen (#9)
Michael Lynagh (#10)
Joe Rokocoko (#11)
Matthew Burke (#15)

Indipper
Ian McLauchlan (#1)
Peter Wheeler (#2)
Frik du Preez (#5)
Fergus Slattery (#7)
Mervyn Davies (#8)
Serge Blanco (#15)

Jamee999
Jason Leonard (#1)
Bill Beaumont (#5)
George Smith (#7)
Lawrence Dallaglio (#8)
Jonah Lomu (#11)
Bryan Habana (#14)

Francis
Gordon Brown (#4)
Willie John McBride (#5)
Ian Kirkpatrick (#6)
Zinzan Brooke (#8)
Ken Catchpole (#9)
Cliff Morgan (#10)

BoyBrumby
Wilson Whineray (#1)
Martin Johnson (#4)
Josh Kronfeld (#7)
Barry John (#10)
Tim Horan (#12)
Christian Cullen (#15)

Chaminda_00
Os du Randt (#1)
Sean Fitzpatrick (#2)
Ian Jones (#4)
Francois Pienaar (#6)
George Gregan (#9)
Phil Bennett (#10)

ripper868
Keith Wood (#2)
Peter Winterbottom (#7)
Nick Farr-Jones (#9)
Naas Botha (#10)
Phillippe Sella (#13)
Gavin Hastings (#15)

ohtani's jacket
Robert Paparemborde (#1)
Jan Lotz (#2)
Graham Price (#3)
Kel Tremain (#6)
Hennie Muller (#8)
Mark Ella (#10)
 

Michaelf7777777

International Debutant
Sorry just remembereed McCall from Eales autobiography I read just over a month ago so I couldn't quite remember his 1st name. Brownlee was #8 for the 1924 invincibles a strong physical hulk of a #8 who legend had it was able to overturn a car using only his hands. Had his greatest game on the invincibles tour in the test against England when after his brother was harshly sent off (Most reports suggest that he either didn't deserve it or that if he did 1 Englishman should of joined him) played a game which many thought was equal to that you would normally expect from two players.
 

Simon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Brad Thorn, former Broncos legend, no idea what position he plays in Union though.
 

Francis

State Vice-Captain
I'll pick Francis Cotton at no. 3. Quite possibly England's greatest ever player. Three times a Lion.

3. Francis Cotton
4. Gordon Brown
5. Willie John McBride
6. Ian Kirkpatrick
8. Zinzan Brooke

9. Ken Catchpole
10. Cliff Morgan
 

Top