Cricket Web

Cricket Web (http://www.cricketweb.net/forum/)
-   Fantasy Cricket (http://www.cricketweb.net/forum/fantasy-cricket/)
-   -   Points assigned to players - Aus/Ind vs Pak/Eng (http://www.cricketweb.net/forum/fantasy-cricket/55034-points-assigned-players-aus-ind-vs-pak-eng.html)

W63l35 04-01-2012 01:28 PM

Points assigned to players - Aus/Ind vs Pak/Eng
 
Hi,
The points (7-15 & the letter rank A-E) assigned to player for Pak-Eng series are pretty stiff as compared to points assigned to Aus-Eng series. Let me show you the comparison:

1. Total points.

Aus-Ind Series: 354 points assigned to 32 players which is 11.1 point per player.
Pak-Eng Series; 315 points assigned to 31 players which is 10.1 points per player.

This means the players for Eng-Pak series are more expensive...for the total spending points of 125 each for both series.

So can you please increase the total available points from 125 to 135 or lower the cost for each player.

Not convince yet? :) Let me give you a few more differences;

2. Number of Players in each category for both series.
Code:

Category            Points        Nbr of Players in Ind-Aus Series        Nbr of players in Pak-Eng Series
A                15                3                                3
B                13                2                                8
C                11                10                                10
D                9                11                                9
E                7                5                                2
                       
                       
                Total                31                                32


As you can see there are 8 player in B category for Pak-Eng series but only 2 in Ind-Aus series.

3. Some individual rankings.

Code:

Team        Type          Name      Cat            Pts
IND        WK        Dhoni        B        13
AUS        Bat        Ponting        B        13

PAK        Bat        Hafeez        B        13
PAK        Bat        Younis        B        13
PAK        Bowl        Ajmal        B        13
ENG        Bat        Trott        B        13
ENG        Bowl        Bresnan        B        13
ENG        Bowl        Swann        B        13
ENG        Bowl        Broad        B        13
ENG        WK        Prior        B        13


IND        Bat        Laxman        C        11
IND        Bat        Dravid        C        11
IND        Bat        Gambhir        C        11
IND        Bowl        Zaheer        C        11
IND        Bowl        Ishant        C        11
IND        Bowl        Ojha        C        11
AUS        Bat        Clarke        C        11
AUS        Bowl        Siddle        C        11
AUS        Bowl        Patnson        C        11
AUS        WK        Haddin        C        11

PAK        Bat        Azhar        C        11
PAK        Bat        Misbah        C        11
PAK        Bat        U.Akmal        C        11
PAK        Bowl        U. Gul        C        11
PAK        Bowl        Rhaman        C        11
PAK        Bowl        Wahab        C        11
ENG        Bat        Struass        C        11
ENG        Bat        KP        C        11
ENG        Bowl        Tremlet        C        11
ENG        Bowl        Finn        C        11

How can Hafeez be in category B where as Dravid, Laxman, Gambhir, Clarke, KP and Trott in category C?

How can Dravid, Laxman, Gambhir & Clarke (from Ind-Aus) be in the same category C ....as Azhar Ali, Misbah, Umar Akmal (may not even play)?

How can Hussey and Farhat be in the same category (D)?


So.. can you please re-evaluate the points for player in Pak-Eng series?

Thanks.

marc71178 04-01-2012 06:03 PM

The points for all the players have been revamped over the last few weeks, unfortunately we cannot change points when series are in progress so not all of the players have been updated as yet (Dale Steyn is currently a D ranking)

As for the current rankings, that is an effect of England being the best side around, which has come about because a lot of players have been performing at the same time. As for the specific example of Hafeez, it's been argued that on current form he's one of the best openers around, and he can also bowl pretty effectively at times, so he has a higher ranking.

Looking at your questions, I would say that Trott and Pietersen are borderline B/C as well, so I've put them down a bit.

The idea of Fantasy Cricket is that it is meant to be a challenge to select using the limit of points to play with, otherwise everyone would have the same team, and I don't think any changes are possible now without messing up the system (and disadvantaging people who've already selected).

125 points averages out at 9 C's and 2 B's, if you want more higher value players, pick some lower value players!

W63l35 07-01-2012 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by marc71178 (Post 2749427)
The points for all the players have been revamped over the last few weeks, unfortunately we cannot change points when series are in progress so not all of the players have been updated as yet (Dale Steyn is currently a D ranking)

Really appreciate your response. Just to clarify..... I am not asking to revise the ranking/points for series in progress. I am requesting the ranking of players in Pak-Eng series to be lowered which has not begun yet.

Thanks.

James 08-01-2012 03:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by W63l35 (Post 2752722)
Really appreciate your response. Just to clarify..... I am not asking to revise the ranking/points for series in progress. I am requesting the ranking of players in Pak-Eng series to be lowered which has not begun yet.

Thanks.

The India/Australia series is using the old ranking points. All the points for them will be adjusted following the conclusion of the Australia/India Test series which will see them ranked similar to the below.

The feedback we've had to date is that most people prefer the nature of the rankings adjustment so it becomes more difficult and challenging to select a team.

Sachin Tendulkar A
Gautam Gambhir B
Rahul Dravid B
Virender Sehwag B
Zaheer Khan B
Praveen Kumar B
VVS Laxman C
Ishant Sharma C
Pragyan Ojha C
MS Dhoni C
Harbhajan Singh C
Ajinkya Rahane D
Virat Kohli D
Yuvraj Singh D
Ravichandran Ashwin D
Vinay Kumar D
Rohit Sharma D
Suresh Raina D
Abhinav Mukund D
Sreesanth D
Murali Vijay D
Cheteshwar Pujara D
Munaf Patel D
Rudra Pratap Singh D
Rahul Sharma E
Umesh Yadav E
Varun Aaron E
Abhimanyu Mithun E
Wriddhiman Saha E
Amit Mishra E


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:33 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
Copyright ©2001 - 2011, Cricket Web