Right. I hadn't quite got what you were saying. My bad.
Right. I hadn't quite got what you were saying. My bad.
Regarding those who say that FC / List-A players should not play U-19 level cricket as it's "below" them...
Precedent - all the following players were playing FC / List-A cricket before they went on tour to Sri Lanka in the 2003 season. This is the first tour I checked (I was looking for the previous U-19 world cup).
Shahid Yousuf - Playing List-A cricket in 2001/2002 season. Playing FC cricket in 2002/2003 season.
Jahangir Mirza - Playing List-A cricket in 2001/2002 season.
Kaushal Silva - Playing FC cricket in 2001/2002 season. Playing List-A cricket in the 2001/2002 season.
Sulaman Qadir - Playing List-A cricket in 2000/2001 season. Playing FC cricket in 2002/2003 season.
These were just the first four players I looked at in the first tour I looked at. All were playing FC / List-A cricket in Pakistan before a tour went ahead - notably during the Pakistan regular season. Some of them have pretty impressive FC / List-A careers going for them, too.
EDIT: When I say they were playing in a certain season, I mean that's the first season that they were playing that level of cricket, not that it's the only season.
Last edited by Loony BoB; 13-03-2006 at 09:51 AM.
REMEMBER: A couple of years in therapy, you'll get over it.
Proud to have been a member of the CW Colts
It's a cricket tour, why would it be seen as a bunch of wierd boys singing?Originally Posted by mikeW
RIP Fardin Qayyumi (AKA "cricket player"; "Bob"), 1/11/1990 - 15/4/2006
Both of them were spoken about before the WC.Originally Posted by Mr Mxyzptlk
An ordinary tour isn't a World Cup.
Also, how much web coverage do these tours get when they happen?
Compare it to how much domestic cricket gets covered.
Now try and say which is the more important.
marc71178 - President and founding member of AAAS - we don't only appreciate when he does well, but also when he's not quite so good!
Anyone want to join the Society?
Beware the evils of Kit-Kats - they're immoral apparently.
Yousuf - 1 FC gameOriginally Posted by Loony BoB
Mirza - 3 List A games in each season
Silva - can't find him on cricketarchive
Qadir - 1 FC game
These are regulars how exactly?
In real life, people aren't deemed inactive. We have to play rookies because there aren't too many from "the dark ages" left. Plus they sign up with abundant awesome-ness.Originally Posted by marc71178
They were spoken about because of their performance at age level cricket. I don't see why it matters where they're playing the age level cricket. It's the same thing.Originally Posted by marc71178
Besides, it's completely untrue to say that Chawla's reputation wasn't enhanced after the World Cup. It doesn't matter what press he had before. He was not on the verge of Test selection before. That's a fact.
In terms of players getting their reputation enhanced by "meaningless" tours, Jason Mohammed Leon Johnson had their reputations enhanced greatly by their meaningless tours before the World Cup.
Sreesanth said, "Next ball he was beaten and I said, 'is this the King Charles Lara? Who is this impostor, moving around nervously? I should have kept my mouth shut for the next ball - mind you, it was a length ball - Lara just pulled it over the church beyond the boundary! He is a true legend."
In addition to what Sean said, real life teams don't have squads limited to 18 players. The fact is that the player pool is so small that it's all relative. A typical domestic team outside of CWLand has at least twice as many players from which to choose the first 18, then choose 11 from that squad of 18. In CWLand, we only have 18 players to choose 11 from.Originally Posted by marc71178
It's not the same.
I'd like to see where these 36 man squads are in any form of domestic cricket.
I believe he said they pick 18 from the 36 - the 36 including the U-19s, the reserves, etc. who would otherwise play club cricket.
Talking about comparisons, A tour would definitely trump an under-19 tour in terms of media coverage. If were talking about under-19 tours, i think they would be on the same level, or a maybe just a tad lower since usually people who play under-19 may or may not click in the domestic league structure. Reetinder Singh Sodhi for an example. But a under-19 world cup definitely is bigger than the domestic league. No argument.
Member of CW RED
Queensland-Season 7 OD Champions
Currently Managing: NSW
Rahul Dravid: A Real Legend.
Originally Posted by cricket playerOriginally Posted by AussieDominance
I would like to say im all for u/19 tours, but the players selected should be players that will be considered for selection i the future, like Henriques IRL, not players who are currently in the test squad.
Member of CW Green
Kerry O'Keefe - Worlds funniest Commentator
Originally Posted by andyc
All Green players have my full support if they choose to tour, or they if they opt out and stay and play fro Green. The choice is up to each individual.
Would you be of the opinion that Weber and Borcich should come under that description?Originally Posted by age_master
Well in West Indies domestic cricket you've got to pick a squad of 15 or 16 from about a couple hundred. That a good enough example?Originally Posted by marc71178
What about in India where there are countless players about for a team to sign for a season? Way more than 36 I assure you.
What about any English county where there are certainly far more than 36 players to decide the squad for the season? This is evidenced by the FACT that they have reserve squads, age level squads etc etc.
You'd like to see more? Be real.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)